Cape Argus

Death penalty advocates have just one solution - a violent, unworkable one

- KOERT MEYER |

THERE must be other reasons why death penalty propagandi­sts are persisting with their only solution, a violent, unworkable, impractica­l one: “Simple solution to SA’s violent crime”, March 12.

This scourge was tried in our country in the colonial era which spanned more than two centuries, and again by the brutal (also unworkable) apartheid regime for the entire 42 years of its rule.

As usual, this letter contains lies, oversimpli­fications etc, starting with its heading. How on Earth can killing people be classified as a “simple solution” when first, no police force anywhere on this planet can catch all wrongdoers, have the few they do catch convicted in dysfunctio­nal and even (politicise­d) judicial systems as our country is now experienci­ng, and then haul those even fewer unfortunat­e ones who could not afford clever legal brains to get them off the hook to the gallows?

Our country’s conviction rate is one of the lowest in the world, our police are not properly trained, our jails are overcrowde­d and unscrupulo­us defence teams are muddying a dismal system.

There must have been a time long ago when all countries believed in this “simple” solution, only to soon realise that it’s wholly impractica­l to kill so many people.

This is the salient question today’s misguided propagandi­sts should answer: Exactly how are they going to kill 21 000 murderers every year? Gallows will have to operate non-stop, and ours have already been dismantled, now a reminder of our brutal past. What about the rapists, gangsters, arsonists, terrorists, drunk and reckless drivers etc, who also kill many people?

More than half the 194 countries constituti­ng the UN have already abolished it, as they’ve done with slavery, human traffickin­g, child labour etc. The dice are heavily loaded against these false prophets, but persist they will, knowing full well that so many fearful folks will believe their Goebbels-like lies told over and over until they are believed, with devastatin­g results.

In many Middle-Eastern countries people can be executed for changing their religion, called apostasy.

In our country, 136 political activists were hanged, one of them Andrew Zondo, who was convicted by the late Judge Ramon Leon, the father of Tony Leon, former leader of the DA. Is it any wonder that this pitiful party cannot make up their minds whether to support the death penalty or to oppose it?

Who were the judges that sent Solomon Mahlangu, another martyr, and the others to their deaths?

The death penalty is a racist monstrosit­y out to decimate the poor, the marginalis­ed, people who do not look like us, like we see is happening in one of the world’s most violent countries, the USA.

Our country desperatel­y needs a DPIC (Death Penalty Informatio­n Centre) like the one in Washington, so that people can arm themselves with credible informatio­n before these folks’ poison reaches them.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa