Ban on SA poultry goods by Botswana ‘premature’
THE BANNING of South African poultry imports by Botswana and Mozambique because of concerns over an isolated outbreak of Asian highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) was bad news for South Africa and premature, the South African Poultry Association (Sapa) said.
Colin Steenhuisen, the interim general manager of the Egg Organisation of Sapa, said on Friday that they had “unofficially learnt” that Mozambique had closed its borders to South African poultry products.
“What is sad is that the HPAI outbreak is only on one farm, which has been isolated and is in strict quarantine. No new cases have been reported since this isolated one farm. Perhaps the closure of borders is premature,” said Steenhuisen.
The poultry industry has been placed on high alert, and the appropriate biosecurity contingency plans were implemented last week, following the confirmation of H5 avian influenza in a commercial layer flock on the East Rand.
Steenhuisen said the poultry industry would be negatively impacted by any lost sales, locally or internationally.
“The director of animal health, Dr Mpho Maja, is in discussions with Botswana and Mozambique to negotiate the re-opening of their borders, to allow South Africa trade of poultry products to recommence.”
HPAI is an internationally notifiable disease with the OIE (World Organisation for Animal Health). Any country receiving news of an HPAI outbreak from the OIE is entitled to close its borders to protect its industry.
According to Sapa, the HPAI H5 was controlled and isolated to one farm on the East Rand, the birds have been culled and disposed of in line with HPAI protocols, and no new outbreaks had been reported.
Steenhuisen said this was a good sign that the current measures of isolation and quarantining were working.
“The poultry industry is on high alert nationally. The national animal health department and all its countrywide state veterinarians are on high alert,” he said.
“We hope and pray we have this isolated to avoid a repeat of the 2017 outbreak. The egg products from the layer farm concerned have been withdrawn from distribution. Eggs and broiler meat are safe to eat, provided properly cooked and accepted food preparation protocols are practised,” added Steenhuisen.
According to a report by the Bureau for Food and Agricultural Policy (BFAP) to Sapa in February 2018, the outbreak of HPAI had a notable effect on the poultry industry, which was one of South Africa’s largest agricultural sub-sectors.
This retrospective analysis considered biological loss, income foregone and the direct costs associated with the outbreak. Total cull numbers from the reported avian outbreaks in the broiler and layer industries were estimated at 5.4 million birds.
The effect on the layer industry had, however, been much larger than that in the broiler industry, with about 4.7 million birds culled in the laying sector as opposed to about 700 000 birds in the broiler sector, which was predominantly affected at breeder level.
The total biological loss associated with these numbers amounted to slightly more than R317 million. Of this, about 75 percent accrued to the commercial laying industry and its various stages of production.
The direct costs associated with the outbreak were about R40.5m, but they could have been larger given the poor response rate on issues related to the direct costs associated with the outbreak.
In terms of income foregone, the BFAP said the total value was estimated at slightly more than R1.5 billion, which included income lost from egg sales, pullet sales, day-old chick sales and broiler meat sales. Of the total loss, 85 percent accrued to the laying industry.
“It should be noted that the income foregone is not an instantaneous loss, and the impact would be spread over a period of more than two years. It also did not account for company-specific management strategies to mitigate the impact, such as utilisation of excess capacity to reduce the impact on dayold chick volumes.
“This was specifically the case in the broiler industry. Given what is presented in the report, the total loss could amount to around R1.87bn if biological losses, direct costs and possible income foregone are considered.
“This represents 18 percent of the total gross value of egg production in 2016 and 1.6 percent of the total gross value of animal products in 2016,” the analysis said.