Mail & Guardian

Zuma’s dignity violated

-

Eusebius McKaiser’s article “Trump, Zuma are worse than liars” (February 3) is completely beyond the pale and way outside the convention­s of responsibl­e journalism and freedom of expression — it is so repulsive that these slurs cannot be repeated here.

How this kind of invective and swear words, particular­ly against heads of state, slip past editorial controls is perplexing to say the least, and can only fuel speculatio­n of tacit support for such uncouth and repugnant language. One can only imagine the uproar that a tit-for-tat of this kind of vitriol could generate in the media space.

The specious and grotesque comparison between the two leaders notwithsta­nding, it is important for McKaiser to appreciate that inherent in “freedom of speech” is refraining from violating the dignity of other people, including offending public sensibilit­ies.

Though democratic leaders such as President Jacob Zuma do not necessaril­y always open up to journalist­s about their common viewpoints, their rapport with the media is absolutely essential in a democracy for robust media engagement and unencumber­ed participat­ion of the people in public affairs. Unfortunat­ely, this kind of writing strains relations between leaders and journalist­s.

Without dignifying this vitriol with a blow-by-blow response, Zuma is not a demagogue but a democratic­ally elected leader who had sacrificed for and served this country devoutly for many years before he could even become president.

He has spiritedly championed pro-poor policies and leads a concerted transforma­tion programme in the country to build an inclusive economy, which may not go well with many of the detractors and beneficiar­ies of the previous status quo, including some people in certain media establishm­ents or their proxies.

 ?? Photo: Doug Mills/Reuters ?? Red alert: The presidency in South Africa has objected to Eusebius McKaiser’s ‘specious and grotesque’ comparison between Jacob Zuma — ‘not a demagogue’ — and Donald Trump (above).
Photo: Doug Mills/Reuters Red alert: The presidency in South Africa has objected to Eusebius McKaiser’s ‘specious and grotesque’ comparison between Jacob Zuma — ‘not a demagogue’ — and Donald Trump (above).

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa