Minimum wage must not distract
A TRUE LIVING WAGE: PROBABLY IN THE REGION OF R10 000 TO R12 000
Employees can’t live a decent life, employers should work on how to do so.
Business must look beyond the national minimum wage agreement and vigorously explore ways to implement a living wage, says the South African Reward Association (Sara). The phenomenon of “the working poor” is fuelling the ongoing resentment and violent industrial action that increasingly bedevils South African business.
In many senses, the national minimum wage is something of a red herring, because it could distract companies from the need to work towards paying a living wage, rather than just a minimum wage.
The minimum wage does not allow employees to live a decent, dignified life, and employers should therefore devote attention to how to do so. While there is no consensus about what a living wage in South Africa is, it is certainly substantially above the R3 500 minimum wage. Cosatu’s Patrick Craven says that the working poor earn anything below R4 125 a month; A true living wage is probably in the region of R10 000–R 12 000 per month, although there is no “official” living wage figure for South Africa. The British figure is £7-8 per hour.
However, that these adjustments to worker pay need to be done in an economically sustainable way, and that being good stewards of shareholders’ money is also an ethical imperative for directors.
Disclose both top and bo om pay
A consequence is that companies and society as a whole pay a great deal of attention to the rate of executive pay. In fact, companies would find it hard if not impossible to attract top talent if they did not pay a market-related rate. I recommend paying this rate in order to attract leaders of the right calibre but to structure packages carefully to align reward and performance.
An equally intense focus on what the lowest earners are paid would actually tell one more about the true remuneration ethics in play within the company. I believe that companies that are serious about the wage gap and poverty will increasingly disclose both their top and bottom wage-earners, and the detail of what they are doing to assist those at the bottom to manage their money better.
Understand benefit of paying living wage
Research by the United Kingdom-based Living Wage Foundation shows that 93% of companies that have implemented a living wage have seen benefits: 86% cite reputational benefit, 75% say it has increased motivation and retention rates, while 64% identify differentiation as a positive. Particularly relevant for South Africa with its adversarial labour relations, 58% say that paying a living wage improved relations between managers and staff.
Paying a living wage is as much about enlightened self-interest as anything else. Poverty and the resulting social instability are huge issues that have direct, immediate repercussions for companies, but they also affect the overall business environment. Paying a living wage will go some way towards proving business’s commitment to economic justice, and to healing our society.
Martin Hopkins is a master reward specialist, executive committee member at Sara and partner at PwC in the People & Organisation practice.