The Herald (South Africa)

Dodgy ‘Dr Joe’ website down

- Naledi Shange

THE “House call with Dr Joe” column on the Government Employee Medical Scheme (Gems) website has been taken down.

This comes just days after TimesLIVE ran a story about how PR staffers from Martina Nicholson Associatio­ns were allegedly the ones offering medical health advice and not a qualified doctor as perceived.

“Apologies for the inconvenie­nce‚ this page is currently under review‚” was the message displayed on the page where dozens of questions and answers relating to a vast number of health issues from cancer‚ fertility and medication had been listed prior to the story.

Health Profession­s Council of SA spokeswoma­n Priscilla Sekhonyana said they were investigat­ing the allegation­s about the column.

“The HPCSA is currently investigat­ing the matter and once it has been finalised I will inform you accordingl­y‚” she said.

The medical scheme had insisted that the answers had all been supplied by qualified medical practition­ers.

PR company owner Martina Nicholson had last week forwarded a response from Gems chief healthcare officer Vuyo Gqola‚ who said: “All content is approved by medical doctors‚ both prior to being sent on to the member by Gems and also prior to being placed on the website by Gems.”

Nicholson had dismissed claims that she used lay people to offer medical advice to Gems members‚ stating that the scathing allegation­s were made by a disgruntle­d former employee.

She said later her staffers only wrote the top and bottom of the answers.

“The work we do here at MNA is actually only a very small part of an extensive process‚” she said.

Several doctors pointed out mistakes in numerous answers, including one about the cancer risk associated with asymmetric breasts.

A pharmacist said some of the answers were also problemati­c because they suggested treatments.

Diagnosing and treating people over the internet without a full examinatio­n and medical history is illegal.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from South Africa