‘CHAIRMAN PAO’, THE WOMAN SILICON VALLEY LOVES TO HATE
The former Reddit boss had many admirers — and critics — but then everything went badly wrong
At a quick glance, Ellen Pao seems a poster child for the American Dream. The daughter of Chinese immigrants, she collected Ivy League degrees from Princeton and Harvard in electronics, law and business. She married a flashy hedge fund manager who became one of the richest African-Americans in the land.
On the strength of that glittering academic CV, Ms Pao landed a plum job at arguably the most prestigious venture capital outfit in Silicon Valley, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers. Until Friday night she ran Reddit, the 35th most popular social networking and news website on the internet. What went wrong?
The short answer is, j ust about everything. By last Thursday night, almost 213,000 people had signed an online petition demanding that the 45-year-old hand in her resignation. The demise of the woman dubbed by her critics “Chairman Pao” could lead to the undoing of her company.
Born in 1970 in New Jersey, an American child of Chinese heritage, she is fluent in English and Mandarin Chinese. She worked her way through the elite US education system, qualifying as a lawyer before entering the male-dominated world of digital tech. Yet despite her position, little is known about the woman who, until recently, could count herself among only a handful of powerful women at the top of the global digital sector. She appears a very private person — strangely so, given the controversies in which she has been involved.
Admirers say she is quiet and deeply serious. That impression is only reinforced by interviews, in which she comes across as straightforward, sincere and lucid, the corporate good girl par excellence. But critics see another Ms Pao. For them, she is hyper-intense, poor at human relations, and as one put it to Vanity Fair in 2013, a mere “achievement machine”.
All of which casts an interesting light on her very public undoing. Dreams have their dark side, starting with her husband, Alphonse “Buddy” Fletcher, whose business went bankrupt amid allegations of fraud.
His company was likened to a Ponzi scheme and a Manhattan judge ruled that the 49-year-old investor owed his former law firm $2.7m (91 million baht) in unpaid bills in the civil fraud case. Mr Fletcher was her second husband after a brief early marriage.
Just as Mr Fletcher’s empire was crumbling in 2012, Ms Pao’s relationship with the venerable Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers turned terminally sour. After a long failure to win promotion and pay rises like her male counterparts, she became convinced the reason was blatant sexism at the company and filed a $16 million lawsuit alleging gender discrimination.
The case went to court in February this year and the tales that emerged of “boysonly” trips for the bosses, sexual harassment and office affairs (one involving Ms Pao) transfixed the country.
Silicon Valley’s hyper-creative and meritocratic image was revealed to be the same-old culture of corporations worldwide. The case galvanised the cause of equal rights for women at the workplace.
There was just one problem, however. Despite liberal San Francisco being one of America’s most plaintiff-friendly jurisdictions, Ms Pao lost her case.
At the trial, Kleiner Perkins released a 2011 review of her performance, describing Ms Pao as “passive”, a junior partner with a sense of entitlement who was “territorial” and divisive. A poor team player, she was not trusted by her colleagues. And yet this reportedly passive executive had the nerve to take her powerful employers to court, on her own, without co-plaintiffs.
And so to Reddit, where she was appointed interim chief executive last November. Since its foundation over a decade ago, the site — which bills itself as “the front page of the internet” — has grown into a giant. Today, it claims 170 million unique users a month, attracted by its anarchic, anything-goes style, and boasts some 8,000 “sub-reddits” — online communities devoted to topics embracing everything from politics to porn, cricket to cars. Reddit has never made a profit, but that didn’t stop a private $50 million funding last year, valuing the company at $500 million.
Reddit’s lax controls on content, enforced by unpaid “moderators”, had always caused controversy. Enter Ms Pao and these troubles multiplied. First, she closed down various sub-reddits deemed offensive and intimidating, such as one entitled FatPeopleHate. “It’s not our goal to be a completely free-speech platform,” Ms Pao explained. “We want to be a safe platform and we want to be a platform that protects privacy at the same time.”
Users accustomed to pushing the US First Amendment guarantee of free speech were pushed to breaking point, but worse was to come this month when Reddit fired, without explanation or a word of warning, one of its most popular, paid moderators.
Victoria Taylor had been in charge of the site’s most famous attraction, Ask Me Anything, which features live guests ranging from your average Joe to astronauts, film stars and even President Barack Obama (during his 2012 re-election campaign) and tennis ace Roger Federer. When Ms Taylor disappeared, moderators shut off some of the most popular sub-reddits in protest.
Ms Pao produced a grovelling apology, in which she accepted full blame. “We screwed up,” she declared, “not just on July 2, but also over the past several years. We haven’t communicated well … we have apologised and made promises to you, the moderators and the community, over many years, but time and again, we haven’t delivered on them.”
After the petition garnered so much public attention, speculation grew about the fate, not only of Ms Pao, but Reddit itself. The internet, after all, is the ultimate laboratory of ephemera, driven by Darwinian laws of survival.
Why shouldn’t Reddit, owned by publisher Conde Nast, but operating as a fully independent entity, go the way of its spiritual ancestor Digg — still in business, but a shadow of its rip-roaring former self? And what of that apology over Ms Taylor?
The reasons for the sacking may still be unclear, but the assumption of personal responsibility by Ms Pao was remarkable, at least when measured against the weasel words, invariably couched in the passive mood (“errors were made…”), of most corporate mea culpas. Hardly the stuff of an “achievement machine” with an overblown sense of entitlement.
What happens next is anyone’s guess. “Redditors” could start spending more time using other sites such as Facebook, YouTube, Twitter, Tumblr or Buzzfeed, and there are signs that is happening.
But none has quite the same sense of liberty and anything-goes as Reddit.
Ms Pao though was, by common consent, on her way out. Indeed, one popular theory has it that she has been deliberately set up to take the fall, whereby Reddit could press ahead with an unpopular “monetisation” policy — and then fire her in a move depicted as a massive victory for the company’s true believers.
Yes, women have risen to the very top of the tech universe: Marissa Mayer at Yahoo, Virginia Rometty at IBM, Meg Whitman at Hewlett-Packard (where Carly Fiorina once ruled), Sheryl Sandberg at Facebook, to name but a few. For Ms Pao, alas, too much went wrong for her to remain among their number.