Blood but no victory as drug war marks 1 year
Manila’s success claims disputed by critics
MANILA: Launched a year ago, Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte’s brutal war on drugs has resulted in thousands of deaths, yet the street price of crystal methamphetamine in Manila has fallen and surveys show Filipinos are as anxious as ever about crime.
Mr Duterte took power on June 30 last year, vowing to halt the drug abuse and lawlessness he saw as “symptoms of virulent social disease”.
Thanks to his campaign, government officials say, crime has dropped, thousands of drug dealers are behind bars, a million users have registered for treatment, and future generations of Filipinos are being protected from the scourge of drugs.
“There are thousands of people who are being killed, yes,” said Oscar Albayalde, Metro Manila’s police chief said. “But there are millions who live, see?”
A growing chorus of critics, however, including human rights activists, lawyers and the country’s influential Catholic Church, dispute the authorities’ claims of success.
They say police have summarily executed drug suspects with impunity, terrorising poorer communities and exacerbating the very lawlessness they were meant to tackle.
“This president behaves as if he is above the law — that he is the law,” wrote Amado Picardal, an outspoken Filipino priest, in a recent article for a Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines publication. “He has ignored the rule of law and human rights.”
The drug war’s exact death toll is hotly disputed, with critics saying the toll is far above the 5,000 that police have identified as either drug-related killings, or suspects shot dead during police operations.
Most victims are small-time users and dealers, while the masterminds behind the lucrative drug trade are largely unknown and at large, say critics of Mr Duterte’s ruthless methods.
If the strategy was working the laws of economics suggest the price of crystal meth, the highly addictive drug also known as shabu, should be rising as less supply hits the streets. But the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency’s own data suggests shabu has become even cheaper in Manila. In July 2016, a gramme of shabu cost 1,20011,000 pesos (800-7,400 baht), according to agency’s figures. Last month, a gramme cost 1,000-15,000 pesos (670-10,000 baht), it said.
The wide ranges reflect swings in availability and sharp regional variations. Officials say Manila’s street prices are at the lowest end of the range. And that has come down, albeit by just a few dollars.
“If prices have fallen, it’s an indication that enforcement actions have not been effective,” said Gloria Lai of the International Drug Policy Consortium, a global network of non-governmental groups focused on narcotics.
The problem is, according to Derrick Carreon, the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency’s spokesman, that while nine domestic drug labs have been busted, shabu smuggled in from overseas has filled the market gap. “Demand needs to be addressed because there are still drug smugglers,” Mr Carreon said.
While smuggled shabu has kept the price down in the capital, the official data shows the price has gone up in the already substantially more expensive far-flung regions such as Mindanao.
Mr Duterte declared martial law in Mindanao last month after militants inspired by Islamic State stormed Marawi City, and the army’s failure to retake the city quickly has dented the president’s image as a law-and-order president.
Surveys by Social Weather Stations (SWS), a leading Manila pollster, reveal a public broadly supportive of Mr Duterte’s anti-drug campaign, but troubled by its methods and dubious about its effectiveness.
SWS surveys in each of the first three quarters of Mr Duterte’s rule showed a “very high satisfaction” with the antidrug campaign, said Leo Laroza, a senior SWS researcher.
In the most recent survey, published on April, 92% said it was important that drug suspects be captured alive. Respondents also reported a 6.3% rise in street robberies and break-ins. More than half of those polled said they were afraid to venture out at night, a proportion that had barely changed since the drug war began, said Mr Laroza.
“People still have this fear when it comes to their neighbourhoods,” he said. “It has not gone down.”
Public and police perceptions of crime levels seem to diverge. The number of crimes committed in the first nine months of Mr Duterte’s rule has dropped by 30%, according to police statistics cited by the president’s communications team.
Mr Albayalde, the capital’s police chief, said people, particularly in Manila, felt safer now, especially due to a crackdown on drug users who he said commit most of the crime.
In the first 11 months of Mr Duterte’s rule, police say 3,155 suspects were shot dead in anti-drug operations. Critics maintain that many of them were summarily executed. Police say they have investigated a further 2,000 drug-related killings, and have yet to identify a motive in at least another 7,000 murders and homicides.
Human rights monitors believe many of these victims were killed by undercover police or their paid vigilantes, a charge the police deny.
For residents of Navotas fishport, a warren of shacks near Manila’s docks, the body count is too high. There were nine killings in a single night in Navotas earlier this month, according to local media.
In mid-May, said resident Mary Joy Royo, a dozen gunmen arrived on motorbikes and abducted her mother and stepfather. Their corpses were found later with executionstyle gunshots to the head and torso.
“They should be targeting the drug lords,” Ms Royo said. “The victims of the drug war are the poor people.”
As the death toll has risen, so has domestic and international outrage. In October, the Hague-based International Criminal Court said it could investigate the killings if they were “committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack against a civilian population”.
Police operations were halted for much of February after it emerged that anti-drug police abducted and killed a South Korean businessman last year, but the outcry over the rising body count has rarely slowed the killing or led to prosecutions.
The Philippine Commission on Human Rights is investigating 680 drug-war killings.
“In this country the basic problem is impunity,” Chito Gascon, the commission’s chairman, said. “No one is ever held to account for the worst violations. Ever.”
Police chief Albayalde says that the force’s Internal Affairs Service (IAS) investigates all allegations of abuse by his officers. “We do not tolerate senseless killings,” he said. “We do not just kill anybody.”
IAS said it had investigated 1,912 drugrelated cases and recommended 159 officers for dismissal due to misconduct during anti-drug operations, although it didn’t know whether any had yet been dismissed.
Earlier this month, 19 police officers charged with murdering two drug suspects in their jail cell in November were released on bail and now face trial for the lesser crime of homicide.
Mr Duterte, who has repeatedly urged police to kill drug suspects, had already vowed to pardon the officers if they were convicted. “You have a head of state who says, ‘Kill, kill, kill’, a head of state who says, ‘I’ve got your back’,” said CHR’s Mr Gascon. “That has a ripple effect.”