Data: Wind energy cheaper than nuke power

Hinkley Point plans ‘should be rethought’

LONDON: The price of electricity from offshore wind in Britain has dipped below the level guaranteed to Hinkley Point, raising questions about the construction of the vast nuclear power station.

The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy disclosed on Monday the results of auctions for state subsidies for three new wind offshore farms.

Denmark’s Dong Energy A/S won the auction to build Hornsea Two, which will become the world’s biggest offshore wind farm off the coast of Yorkshire in northern England.

Germany’s Innogy SE and Norway’s Statkraft AS won the auction for Triton Knoll off Lincolnshire in eastern England, while Moray in Scotland was won by a consortium comprising EDP Renovaveis SA of Portugal and Engie SA of France.

“The projects, which are set to generate over three gigawatts of electricity, enough to power 3.6 million homes, demonstrate that the UK continues to be an attractive place to invest in clean energy,” the department said in a statement.

The companies lodged bids for the socalled “strike price” they will be paid by the state for electricity generated, with the lowest amounts securing the deals.

Those prices have tumbled to £74.75 ($98.52) per megawatt hour for projects deliverable in 2021/2022, and to £57.50 for projects due in 2022/2023.

The price of offshore wind has fallen far below that of nuclear, with the planned Hinkley Point C power plant in southwestern England having secured subsidies of £92.50 per megawatt hour.

The gigantic Hinkley project was awarded to a French-Chinese consortium — led by French giant EDF — last year but has been plagued by long delays and cost overruns.

“Today’s results mean that both onshore and offshore wind are cheaper than gas and nuclear,” noted trade body RenewableUK in a statement on Monday.

However, the Nuclear Industry Association cautioned in another statement that “one technology alone can’t solve the UK’s power challenge”.

Wind and solar production have the drawback of being unpredictable, with countries needing to call on gas, coal or nuclear plants to raise output if there is no breeze or sun.

British government wind power subsidies have now halved since the last auction was held in 2015.

Environmentalists have long urged the government to focus on renewable sources like wind and solar power to meet Britain’s energy needs.

Opponents have criticised the high guaranteed Hinkley price level, which is fixed over 35 years and rises with inflation.

Lawmaker Caroline Lucas, co-leader of the Green Party, said the massive price drop for offshore wind should be the “nail in the coffin” for new nuclear power.

“The government’s undying commitment to new nuclear risks locking us into sky-high prices for years to come,” she warned.

Meanwhile, Michael Ware, partner at BDO’s corporate finance division, said Monday’s announcement raised questions over the future of tidal and wave energy — which are more costly.

“We were pleasantly surprised by the low price bids in the latest auction,” he told AFP, describing it a “vindication” of government policy.

“However, it does beg the obvious question of where a £57.50 strike price leaves other nascent technologies, such as tidal and wave, which are probably not economically viable at that level.

“It also puts the (price) being paid for Hinkley Point into sharp perspective.”

Nevertheless, Ware added that it was “a big step forward in the transition to a renewable (energy) grid”.