CNN, White House go head to head
Outspoken newsman Acosta, Trump spokeswoman Sanders tussle over president’s latest anti-media outburst
Jim Acosta, the square-jawed CNN correspondent, has stood out among the White House press corps for his impassioned on-air monologues about the importance of the First Amendment. During a tense White House briefing late last week, challenged the press secretary, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, to disavow President Donald Trump’s description of journalists as “the enemy of the people”. Ms Sanders declined to do so, saying she had been personally attacked in the media and had faced threats since starting her job. Opinions on the exchange varied. Many liberals praised Acosta for confronting Sanders, particularly after he had faced vitriol from Mr Trump supporters at a Florida rally on Tuesday. Many conservatives knocked Acosta as a biased showboat. And some of his rival White House reporters rolled their eyes.
Acosta, a CNN veteran, is used to it. Since January, when the president-elect shouted him down at a news conference, Acosta, 47, has been a featured player in the Trump v Media battle royale. The president, no fan of CNN, has called Acosta “a real beauty” and refused to take his questions last month during a session with reporters in Britain.
All that has made Acosta a ripe target for Mr Trump’s army of adherents. This week, Sean Hannity of Fox News ran a montage of “Jim Acosta Lowlights” and called him “a liberal partisan hack”. In Florida, Acosta, who is regularly escorted to rallies by security personnel, faced hostile Trump fans who interrupted his live shot and shouted “fake news”.
That set the stage for Thursday, when Acosta, breaking from the usual sober style of White House reporters, framed his question to Sanders as a moral choice.
“It would be a good thing if you were to state right here, at this briefing, that the press — the people who are gathered in this room right now, doing their jobs every day, asking questions of officials like the ones you brought forward earlier — are not the enemy of the people,” Acosta said in his newscaster’s baritone. “I think we deserve that.”
Sanders deflected — and then mirrored Acosta’s tone.
“It’s ironic, Jim,” she said, “that not only you and the media attack the president for his rhetoric, when they frequently lower the level of conversation in this country.”
Sanders, without much evidence, went on to accuse the news media of using “personal attacks without any content other than to incite anger”. She also cited her experience at this year’s White House Correspondents Association dinner, during which comedian Michelle Wolf mocked Sanders’ “smoky eye” makeup and compared her to “an Uncle Tom” for “white women.”
“You brought up a comedian to attack my appearance and call me a traitor to my own gender,” Sanders said. “As far as I know, I’m the first press secretary in the history of the United States that’s required Secret Service protection.”
Her answer did not directly address the question, so Acosta tried again, with more oomph.
“This democracy, this country, all the people around the world watching what you are saying, Sarah, and the White House for the United States of America — the president of the United States should not refer to us as ‘the enemy of the people’, ” he said. “His own daughter acknowledges that, and all I’m asking you to do, Sarah, is to acknowledge that right now and right here.”
Sanders replied: “I appreciate your passion. I share it. I’ve addressed this question.” At that, Acosta promptly walked out. Those watching the exchange on television would have noticed the faces of Acosta’s fellow correspondents, some watching with curiosity and others averting their gaze.
“I don’t understand why it matters if Sarah Huckabee Sanders says she doesn’t think the media are the enemy of the people,” said Alex Pareene, a liberal commentator who has written for Splinter, Gawker and Wonkette. “She isn’t the White House or the president. Her words would be meaningless and would have no effect on either Trump’s supporters or even the president himself.”
Mr Pareene added, “It just seems silly and self-righteous, even if I guess it is still notable or newsworthy that the White House press secretary can’t bring herself to make some anodyne statement of support for the press.”
For his part, Acosta was cheered on by his CNN colleagues. He later wrote on Twitter that he was “totally saddened by what just happened”.
“Sarah Sanders was repeatedly given a chance to say the press is not the enemy and she wouldn’t do it,” he wrote in a post that received a torrent of retweets. “Shameful.”
Around the same time, a United Nations group condemned Mr Trump’s “repeated attacks on the free press.”
“His attacks are strategic, designed to undermine confidence in reporting and raise doubts about verifiable facts,” wrote the United Nations and the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights.
Mr Trump resumed his customary denigration of the press at a rally in Pennsylvania on Thursday night, pointing at the journalists in the arena and telling the crowd, “They can make anything bad. They are the fake, fake disgusting news.”
Mr Trump unleashed a torrent of grievances at the rally in which he cast journalists as his true political opponent. “Whatever happened to the free press? Whatever happened to honest reporting?’’ Trump asked, pointing to the media in the back of the room. “They don’t report it. They only make up stories.’’
Time and time again, Mr Trump denounced the press for underselling his accomplishments and doubting his political rise. He tore into the media for diminishing what he accomplished at his Singapore summit with North Korea leader Kim Jong-un. He complained about the tough questioning he received in Helsinki when he met Russia’s Vladimir Putin last month. And he began his rally speech with a 10-minute remembrance of his 2016 election night victory, bemoaning that Pennsylvania wasn’t the state to clinch the White House for him only because “the fake news refused to call it’’.
“They were suffering that night, they were suffering,’’ Mr Trump said of the election-night pundits. He then promised that the Keystone State would deliver his margin of victory “next time’’.
“Only negative stories from the fakers back there,’’ the president declared. With each denunciation, the crowd jeered and screamed at the press in the holding pen.
Before her father’s comments, or Sanders’ argument with CNN, president’s daughter Ivanka Trump took a softer line.
She appeared to break step with two of the most contentious issues surrounding her father’s administration: She disagreed with Mr Trump’s position that the press is the enemy of the people, and she said the administration’s hard-line stance on immigration that resulted in separating children from their parents was a “low point” during her time in the White House.
When asked during an interview with the news site Axios whether she shared her father’s vitriol for the news media, Ms Trump, a senior adviser to the president, said, “I do not”.
Ms Trump, the president’s eldest daughter, said shared some of his complaints about the media, but stopped short of condemning journalists. “I’ve certainly received my fair share of reporting on me personally that I know not to be fully accurate, so I have some sensitivity around why people have concerns and gripe, especially when they’re sort of targeted,” she said. “But no, I do not feel that the media is the enemy of the people.”