End of the ATM?
Cashless payment boom in China and India pressures banks to revise their business models or perish. By Yohei Hirose in Tokyo
● The number of automated teller machines worldwide has started falling as big economies increasingly go cashless.
With cash payments declining, banks are having to quickly rethink their business models to survive. Cashless technologies including cryptocurrencies and QR codes are radically changing the competitive dynamics of the financial services industry and raising new challenges for regulators.
The total number of ATMs around the world fell for the first time in 2018, slipping 1% to 3.24 million units, according to Retail Banking Research (RBR), a British company specialising in banking technology, cards and payments.
In China, the world’s largest market, the number of ATMs fell 6.8% to 690,000. The United States, the second-largest ATM market, saw the total drop 0.9% to 433,500.
“In China, the swift adoption of non-cash payments has contributed to a similarly rapid fall in ATM installations,” RBR said. Smartphone payment services that use QR codes have spread rapidly, leading millions of Chinese people to carry less cash. These cashless consumers hardly handle paper money or coins, and seldom if ever visit banks or use ATMs.
In the US “branch closures have led to fewer bank ATMs”, according to RBR. In India, the third-largest ATM market, “growth slowed considerably”, the company said.
In cash-loving Japan, which ranks fourth, the number of machines slipped 0.2% to 202,300. This indicates a major shift — ATMs became ubiquitous in Japan over the last two decades as machines were installed in convenience stores. But the number is falling even in Japan.
On July 5, MUFG Bank and Sumitomo Mitsui Banking announced they would make their ATMs outside their branches available to each other’s customers, starting in September. The move will allow the two to close a total of 600 to 700 ATM locations. With the cost of operating ATMs weighing heavily on banks’ bottom lines, more such moves are likely in the future.
Many banks are also closing branches. The total number of branches in the in the 36-member Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, a grouping of developed economies, fell 2.8% in 2017 to 268,900, according to data from the International Monetary Fund. Figures exclude the UK, for which data was unavailable.
The trend continued into 2018; the figure for 30 OECD countries that have published data fell 2.6%.
Customers are increasingly banking online, reducing the need for physical locations. JPMorgan Chase, a US bank, operated 5,028 branches at the end of March 2019, down 11% from five years earlier. On the other hand, the number of subscribers to its mobile banking services surged 110% over the same period.
Japanese banks are also shrinking their networks. Mizuho Financial Group plans to close 130 branches by fiscal 2024, while MUFG Bank, the banking unit of Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group, will prune its network by about 180 locations by 2023.
Driving the decline in brick-andmortar financial services is the fall in cash transactions and growing use of cashless payments, including credit cards, contactless payments, cryptocurrencies and fintech-based services.
While there are still 1.7 billion people worldwide without bank accounts, twothirds of those people have mobile phones that can access online financial services, according to the World Bank. Low-cost crypto remittance services that do not involve banks have also emerged.
In June, Facebook announced a plan to launch its own digital currency, called Libra. The world’s largest social media company, with 2.7 billion users worldwide, has pledged to work with regulators to create a system that protects users’ data and ensures the stability of the cryptocurrency. If Libra takes off, many people could use it, even if they do not have bank accounts.
The evolution of cryptocurrencies and digital banking services could help foster financial inclusion, helping make financial services available at low cost, even to people and businesses that have little or no contact with traditional banks.
The Bank for International Settlements, however, warns that the development of cryptocurrencies and other new technologies presents risks for the poor. The lack of access to conventional payment systems “could push people into using unregulated and potentially unsafe shadow payments”, the financial institution said.
While fintech is making financial services more efficient and accessible to more people, its rise is creating new regulatory challenges, most notably the need to stamp out the use of new technologies for illegal transactions and money laundering.
While there are still 1.7 billion people worldwide without bank accounts, two-thirds of those people have mobile phones that can access online financial services