S Korea pushes tourism in bid to woo North
Seoul faces tricky balancing act as US sanctions weigh heavy on cross-border relations, writes Hyonhee Shin
South Korea’s push to resume tourism with the North is aimed at resetting border ties, but must overcome Pyongyang’s scepticism and chart a careful course around US efforts to pressure leader Kim Jong-un into eliminating his nuclear arsenal.
South Korea’s Unification Ministry unveiled plans this week for individual tours in the North’s major tourist sites. The effort is meant to appease Pyongyang, which has criticised the South for lacklustre progress after their leaders agreed to restart economic cooperation in 2018.
Tourism is not subject to international sanctions imposed over North Korea’s nuclear and missile programmes, and the proposals are designed to avoid breaching UN bans on bulk cash transfers and joint business ventures with North Korea.
Seoul says the United States knows of its plans, and South Korean officials are seeking to sound out Pyongyang about them, albeit quietly given the sensitivity of relations, officials said.
After President Moon Jae-in called for reopening North Korea tours in his New Year speech, Seoul diplomats led by nuclear envoy Lee Dohoon visited Washington. US officials, including Deputy Secretary of State Stephen Biegun, reacted well to the idea, said a diplomatic source, speaking anonymously.
“Biegun practically gave a blank cheque. But of course it doesn’t mean that they want to see a million dollars written down on it right away,” the source said, referring to sanctions concerns.
Officials and businessmen are concerned that the North will not welcome the offer.
In November, Pyongyang threatened to bulldoze “backward, shabby” South Korean tourist facilities at its Mount Kumgang resort. At a key policymaking meeting last month, it vowed to overcome economic difficulties on its own through “an offensive for frontal breakthrough”.
“It would be a policy shift if the North accepts it,” a South Korean official told Reuters, referring to the tourism plan. “And frosty relations aside, they don’t really like South Koreans roaming through their country.”
Amid stalled nuclear talks with Washington, the North has effectively halted formal inter-Korean dialogue after three summits and a flurry of diplomacy in 2017-18, criticising what it calls the South’s US-reliant policy.
“I’m not sure if restarting tourism with the South is in line with their ‘frontal breakthrough’ campaign, but there can always be a surprise, and some of the plans such as invitation-based visits are already taking place on a limited scale,” said an official at a South Korean company previously involved in the initiative.
SANCTIONS
South Korean officials and those who are close to President Moon have increasingly grumbled about Washington’s position that it will maintain sanctions until Pyongyang takes substantial steps toward denuclearisation.
Harry Harris, the US ambassador to South Korea, bore the brunt of that discontent after suggesting Seoul run its tourism idea through a joint working group. Jeong Se-hyun, a former unification minister who advises Mr Moon, called for designating Ambassador Harris as a “persona non grata”.
During the recent meeting led by Messrs Biegun and Lee, both sides shared concerns the US was being perceived as a potential obstacle to inter-Korean ties, the diplomatic source said.
“So we’ll try to give the impression that the consultations are working and helpful, and we can also speed up the way we handle things,” the source said.
Kumgang tourism was a joint venture, now banned by sanctions, that provided a rare source of cash for Pyongyang worth millions of dollars a year. Visitor numbers peaked in 2007 at 350,000, with up to 2,000 crossing the border daily, the industry official said.
Seoul’s new proposal includes not only Kumgang but also new areas built up under Mr Kim, including the Wonsan coastal tourist zone, the Samjiyon alpine town and Yangdok.
A coalition of pro-engagement groups in border areas, which has been taking tentative applications for individual tours, told Reuters that nearly 800 South Koreans have expressed interest since late October.
“Sanctions are the most powerful tool the US has to keep the negotiations alive, so they would have reservations about anything that could possibly undermine the spirit of sanctions,” another diplomatic source said.
“But now that there’s clearance from Washington, Seoul would need to craft a smart strategy to convince North Koreans before throwing the ball back into their court.”
‘‘
It would be a policy shift for the North ... they don’t like South Koreans roaming through their country.