Are prisons turning into terror incubators?
IRAQ IS HOLDING 19,000 IN OVERCROWDED PRISONS WITH LITTLE GOVERNMENT OVERSIGHT
Iraq has detained or imprisoned at least 19,000 people accused of connections to Daesh or other terrorrelated offences, and sentenced more than 3,000 of them to death, according to an analysis by The Associated Press.
The mass incarceration and speed of guilty verdicts raise concerns over potential miscarriages of justice — and worries that jailed militants are recruiting within the general prison population to build new extremist networks.
The AP count is based partially on an analysis of a spreadsheet listing all 27,849 people imprisoned in Iraq as of late January, provided by an official who requested anonymity because he was not authorised to speak to the media. Thousands more also are believed to be held in detention by other bodies, including the Federal Police, military intelligence and Kurdish forces. Those exact figures could not be immediately obtained.
The AP determined that 8,861 of the prisoners listed in the spreadsheet were convicted of terrorism-related charges since the beginning of 2013 — arrests overwhelmingly likely to be linked to Daesh, according to an intelligence figure in Baghdad.
In addition, another 11,000 people currently are being detained by the intelligence branch of the Interior Ministry, undergoing interrogation or awaiting trial, a second intelligence official said. Both intelligence officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to brief the press.
“There’s been great overcrowding ... Iraq needs a large number of investigators and judges to resolve this issue,” Fadhel Al Gharwari, a member of Iraqi’s parliament-appointed human rights commission, told the AP.
Al Gharwari said many legal proceedings have been delayed because the country lacks the resources to respond to the spike in incarcerations.
Large numbers of Iraqis were detained during the 2000s, when the US and Iraqi governments were battling Sunni militants, including Al Qaida, and Shiite militias.
In 2007, at the height of the fighting, the US military held 25,000 detainees.
The spreadsheet obtained by the AP showed that about 6,000 people arrested on terror charges before 2013 still are serving those sentences.
But the current wave of detentions has hit the Iraqi justice system much harder because past arrests were spread out over a much longer period and the largest numbers of detainees were held by the American military, with only a portion sent to Iraqi courts and the rest released.
Human Rights Watch warned in November that the broad use of terrorism laws meant those with minimal connections to Daesh are caught up in prosecutions alongside those behind the worst abuses.
The group estimated a similar number of detainees and prisoners — about 20,000 in all.
“Based on all my meetings with senior government officials, I get the sense that no one — perhaps not even the prime minster himself — knows the full number of detainees,” said Belkis Wille, the organisation’s senior Iraq researcher.
Prime Minister Haider Al Abadi, who is running to retain his position in national elections slated for May, has repeatedly called for accelerated death sentences for those charged with terrorism.
The spreadsheet analysed by the AP showed that 3,130 prisoners have been sentenced to death on terrorism charges since 2013.
Since 2014, about 250 executions of convicted Daesh members have been carried out, according to the Baghdad-based intelligence official.
About 100 of those took place last year, a sign of the accelerating pace of hangings.
The UN has warned that fasttracking executions puts innocent people at greater risk of being convicted and executed, “resulting in gross, irreversible miscarriages of justice.”
The rising number of those detained and imprisoned reflects the more than four-year fight against Daesh, which first formed in 2013 and conquered nearly a third of Iraq and neighbouring Syria the next year.
Iraqi and Kurdish forces, backed by a US-led coalition, eventually rolled the group back on both sides of the border, regaining nearly all of the territory by the end of last year.
30-minute trials
Throughout the fighting, Iraq has pushed thousands of Daesh suspects through trials in counterterrorism courts. Trials witnessed by the AP and human rights groups often took no longer than 30 minutes. The vast majority were convicted under Iraq’s Terrorism Law, which has been criticised as overly broad.
Asked about the process, Sa’ad Al Hadithi, a government spokesman, said, “The government is intent that every criminal and terrorist receive just punishment.”
The largest concentration of those with Daesh-related convictions is in Nasiriyah Central Prison, about 320km southeast of Baghdad, a sprawling maximumsecurity complex housing more than 6,000 people accused of terrorism-related offences.
Extremist teachings
Cells designed to hold two prisoners now hold six, according to a prison official who spoke on condition of anonymity in line with regulations.
The official said overcrowding makes it difficult to segregate prisoners charged with terrorism and that an inadequate number of guards means Daesh members are openly promoting their ideology inside the prison.
Though prisoners at Nasiriyah were banned last year from giving sermons and recruiting fellow inmates, the official said he still witnesses prisoners circulating extremist religious teachings.
In wards holding mostly terror-related convicts, high-ranking Daesh members have banned prisoners from watching television. Many refuse to eat meat from the cafeteria, believing it hasn’t been prepared according to religious guidelines, the prison official said.
The Bucca phenomenon
The relative free rein for extremists is reminiscent of Bucca Prison, a now-closed facility that the US military ran in southern Iraq in the 2000s.
The facility proved a petri dish where militant detainees mingled — including the man who now leads Daesh, Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi, who spent nearly five years there, joining with other militants who became prominent in the group.
“We will never allow Bucca to happen again,” said an Interior Ministry officer overseeing the detention of Daesh suspects in the Mosul area, also speaking on condition of anonymity in line with regulations.
“The Americans freed their captives; under Iraq, they will all receive the death penalty,” he said.
Cellphone signal jammers are installed at prisons holding Daesh suspects. But in Nasiriyah, the prison official said inmates appear to remain in contact with the outside. He recounted how just days after a guard disciplined a senior Daesh member in the prison, the man threatened the guard’s family, listing the names and ages of his children.
The head of the International Red Cross, an organisation that regularly visits prison and detention facilities in Iraq, warned that mass detentions often incite future cycles of violence.
“It’s the tortures, the ill treatments, the continuous long-term bad conditions in detentions which have radicalised a lot of actors which we find again as armed actors on the battlefield,” ICRC President Peter Maurer said during a recent visit to Iraq.
It’s the tortures, the ill treatments, the bad conditions in detentions which have radicalised a lot of actors which we find again as armed actors on the battlefield.”
Peter Maurer |
ICRC President
Based on all my meetings with senior government officials, I get the sense that no one — perhaps not even the prime minster himself — knows the full number of detainees.”
Belkis Wille |
HRW senior Iraq researcher