Retired grammarian scolds White House
Surprised by Trump’s ‘poorly worded’ reply
The notes were sprawled across a letter bearing President Donald Trump’s signature.
In the top left corner: “Have y’all tried grammar style check?”
At the top right: “Federal is capitalised only when used as part of a proper noun.”
And toward the bottom: “OMG this is WRONG!”
The letter, dated May 3 and printed on White House stationery, was addressed to Yvonne Mason, 61, a former high school English teacher who retired in 2017 but hadn’t quite left “grading-paper mode,” she said Sunday.
So when she received the letter in the mail, she pulled out her go-to purple pen and started making corrections. Then she snapped a picture, posted the letter on Facebook and mailed it back to the White House.
“It was a poorly worded missive,” she said. “Poor writing is not something I abide. If someone is capable of doing better, then they should do better.”
‘Visit victims’ families’
Mason, a Democrat who lives in Atlanta, had written to Trump to ask that he visit each family of those who died in the shooting that killed 17 people at a school in Parkland, Florida, in February. “I had written to them in anger, to tell you the truth,” she said. “I thought he owed it to these grieving families.”
The letter she received did not address her concerns, she said. Instead, it listed a series of actions taken after the shooting, such as listening sessions, meetings with lawmakers and the Stop School Violence Act, a bill that would authorise $500 million over 10 years for safety improvements at schools but had no provisions related to guns.
A sentence about a “rule” banning devices that turn legal guns into illegal machine guns was unclear. “Explain ‘rule,’” she wrote.
There was more, but she didn’t correct everything. “I did not mention the dangling modifier,” she said. “I focused mainly on mechanics.”
“Nation” was capitalised, so was “states.” Mason circled both.
However, a style manual for the federal government calls for capitalising “Nation” and “Federal” when the words are used as a synonym for the United States. It says “State” should be capitalised when it is referring to the government or legislature. In letters from Presidents Barack Obama and George W. Bush that constituents posted online, words like “Nation” and “President” are capitalised.
The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The letter stood in contrast to other letters she has received from politicians, Mason said. Sen. Lindsey Graham, Republican-South Carolina, sent “beautiful letters that struck a tone that makes me more important than him.”
She has written to several legislators in South Carolina, where she taught Advanced Placement English language and composition.