Progressive, but some changes are needed

VAR is a worthy addition and should have been introduced earlier, however its implementation by Fifa especially at the international level matches is a horrible decision. Firstly because rules in which VAR is allowed to be used is if it’s a ‘clear error’ but what exactly constitutes that is still unknown. VAR would be of better help in situations which are unclear in a match but this very rule sort of impedes the idea of implementing VAR. In two different matches but same scenario, I have seen one had VAR implemented to award a rightful penalty, and one where it wasn’t called into question at all.

VAR was only trialed on the big stage at the 2017 Fifa Confederations Cup prior to World Cup. Most teams are only becoming accustomed to idea of VAR at the grandest stage itself. Given VAR is now part of football’s laws, VAR should have been properly trialed in domestic leagues for a few years before making an entrance on the international stage.

Also, communication is a huge issue. For example, third umpires in cricket communicate their decision and it can be heard on live television. Football needs something similar. If not to the public, at least the head referee needs to be able to communicate with the players and coaches on the pitch about why VAR is being consulted. Moreover, a limit needs to be set regarding using the VAR, because given the ‘clear error’ scenario, it will encourage players to play fairer.

From Mr Murtaza Ali Khan

Master’s degree student of chemical engineering based in Abu Dhabi