NEW VARIANT CAUSES SURGE IN GLOBAL CORONAVIRUS INFECTIONS
▶ Experts divided over whether restrictions must be introduced to control spread of Covid-19
Many countries are experiencing a surge in coronavirus infections, as a new variant has spread around the world.
The World Health Organisation designated JN. 1 as a “variant of interest” last week, after it was detected in China, India and the US.
Medical experts who spoke to The National had mixed views on whether controls and restrictions on movement were realistic, given that much of the global population has some level of immunity.
At least 700 million cases were officially recorded during the pandemic that killed 6.9 million people, and the actual number of cases is widely believed to have been much higher.
Dr Bharat Pankhania, a senior consultant in communicable disease control and senior clinical lecturer at the University of Exeter in England, said that new variants are emerging “all the time”.
“Is it spreading faster? I don’t think so; it’s more a case of people have dropped their infection-prevention guard,” he said.
He said he was concerned people were “underimmunised” at a time when there was “a lot of socialising” that could spread the virus.
“[There is a] strong perception that a virus comes, it mutates, then becomes like the common cold. That’s not always the case,” he said.
“I think governments should take it seriously. Here, in the UK, we have no public health messaging [saying]: ‘The virus is here to stay, don’t get infected. If you’re unwell and by yourself, try not to spread it to others.’”
JN. 1 was identified in the US in September and has since spread so widely that it now makes up a growing proportion of cases in many countries.
While the WHO has said JN. 1 poses a “low” public health risk, the organisation has also warned that, with the northern hemisphere experiencing winter, the variant “could increase the burden of respiratory infections in many countries”.
Ian Jones, professor of virology at the University of Reading in Britain, said it was “always concerning” if a new variant is significant enough to spread through the population. He said there was a worry that any new variant, if sufficiently different from previous ones, would be better able to evade the immune protection that people had developed against Covid-19.
However, he said, JN. 1 does not currently appear to be creating a much greater threat.
“I still don’t think there’s evidence it’s an alarming development,” he said.
“We have to keep in mind anything that spreads will find those particular individuals, people who will become poorly. For them, it’s important to keep up to date with the vaccine.”
While JN. 1 has mutations that distinguish it from the Omicron or the B. 1.1.529 variant, it is more directly descended from the BA. 2.86 variant. A study published last week in The Lancet medical journal indicated that JN. 1 could have “significantly enhanced” ability to evade the immune response to Covid-19 compared to BA. 2.86.
However, Paul Hunter, professor of medicine at the University of East Anglia in England, said “at the moment there’s no evidence” that JN. 1 is likely to cause more severe illness than other forms of Sars-CoV-2.
While it was spreading more quickly than other variants, he said it was not doing so “overwhelmingly more” than other variants did when they appeared.
Prof Hunter said a Covid-19 infection this year “is much less likely” to cause an illness severe enough to cause a person to have to go to hospital, compared to the same time last year.
“If you caught Covid this time last year, you were probably two to three times more likely to end up in hospital than if you caught Covid this year,” he said.
“It’s a lot less severe than last year, and last year was a lot less severe than the previous year. There’s quite a bit of evidence Covid isn’t as severe as a year ago.”
He said the reduction in the severity of disease was likely to be the result of people having built up immunity through repeated infections, but also because the virus had evolved to become less pathogenic.
“Almost all of us have had repeated infections, whether we know it or not,” Prof Hunter said. “It’s very unlikely we’ll see anything close to the same pressures on healthcare services we saw even a year ago.”
He added that on “the balance of evidence” introducing stricter restrictions now to try to curb the spread of Sars-CoV-2 “would not be that helpful”.
“I’m not convinced that non-pharmaceutical interventions – being cautious – actually helps anyone,” he said.
“The latest data [in Britain] suggests one in 30 people are currently infected with Covid. Every bus you get on, there will be an average of one person with Covid.
“If we went back to restrictions, I don’t think it would make a blind bit of difference.”
JN.1 was designated as a ‘variant of interest’ by the WHO last week after it was detected in China, India and the US