Neighbours object to ‘overbearing’ Jewellery Quarter plans
A CONTROVERSIAL development that will keep a 200-year-old business in the Jewellery Quarter will go ahead despite scathing objections from locals.
Birmingham City Council planning committee narrowly passed the scheme for Charles Green & Son in Tenby Street.
It will see the demolition of the current 1960s building to be replaced by a four-storey development that will house the new company premises, provide extra commercial space and create 37 flats.
A company statement said it will enable the firm to stay in the area where it has been based for 200 years and retain 30 jobs.
But the plan sparked a storm of protest from neighbours as well as heritage groups worried about the impact it would have.
While welcoming the demolition of the 1960s building, Historic England, The Victorian Society and the Jewellery Quarter Development Trust all said it would harm the character of the conservation area. A number of residents also had objections, claiming they would lose light, privacy and see extra pressure on car parking spaces. Jasmine Gardosi said: “Aside from grossly violating Jewellery Quarter guidelines to maintain and honour the character of the area, a loss of privacy and overlooking of those neighbouring properties presents a real problem. “The overbearing and oppressive visual of the development would also make the street dark and unattractive. We ask if the retention of Charles Green business can be achieved without sacrificing the character of the conservation of the area.”
Tom Green, chairman of Charles
Green & Son, said: “The scheme will remove an existing 1960s building which detracts from the character and appearance of the area, boost housing supply including affordable and specifically for key workers and those who are in the jewellery trade. It would provide additional commercial trade space as part of the mixed of uses, enhance the vibrancy and activity in the area and increased spending in the locality.”
Cllr Lou Robson said: “This application drives a coach and horses through the conservation and design guidance for the Jewellery Quarter.”