Daily Mail

How could they not have heard of Ward’s ordeal?

- By IAN HERBERT

To be fair, Martin Glenn had just taken one hell of a beating by MPs. But the look of utter bewilderme­nt in his eyes late on Wednesday when Sportsmail asked him if he really had not heard of the discrimina­tion Lucy Ward endured at Leeds United said everything about the organisati­on he runs.

The FA chief executive said Ward’s case — which commanded national profile last year — might have escaped the governing body’s attention because the club’s former owner Massimo Cellino ‘has now left’.

Some elementary inquiries at Wembley will tell Glenn (below) that Ward tried for 18 months to persuade the FA to examine the conduct of two former Leeds executives — Adam Pearson and Stuart Hayton — who sacked her and then watched a public character assassinat­ion when she took them to industrial tribunal. You really needed to be there to understand what the respected former academy welfare officer was put through in that courtroom, though relatively few were. The Daily Mail was one of only two national titles to cover the case. There was a swagger and bombast about Pearson as he watched Leeds United’s barrister undertake a vicious and calculated attack on Ward — seeking to denigrate her as a ‘ controllin­g’ woman to justify the club showing her the door.

Then the local media coverage delivered headlines about the club’s evidence. They were haunting for a former player who, in 11 years as Leeds welfare and education officer, had helped the developmen­t of around 250 young players at the academy, including James Milner, Fabian Delph and Sam Byram.

‘She ruled the club,’ read one. ‘ People didn’t like her,’ ran another. There was the usual Twitter hate, of course.

on every human level, the treatment of Ward made your blood boil. Sacked on the flimsy pretence that she had failed to ask permission for a leave of absence to commentate for the BBC on the Women’s World Cup in Canada, she initially found it difficult to get back into football. Employers are notoriousl­y suspicious of job applicants who have brought a successful unfair dismissal claim.

It was out of a determinat­ion to ensure that — as she put it last year — ‘someone else’s daughter’ didn’t have to go through what she did that Ward urged the FA to pursue disciplina­ry proceeding­s against Cellino, Pearson and Hayton, under FA Rule E3, which governs sex discrimina­tion. The FA always seem very willing to do this when cases are in the public limelight. David Moyes was charged and fined £30,000 last season after telling a female BBC interviewe­r she was risking a ‘slap’ for her line of post-match questionin­g. But it was a different story for Ward, who stood before a brick wall of FA bureaucrac­y.

Months of FA inaction had elapsed before she tried emailing the governing body’s head of integrity, Jenni Kennedy. Despite the nature of her case, it was one of Kennedy’s staff who telephoned Ward back. Emails never seem to elicit emails in these cases. Aluko told MPs on Wednesday how reluctant the governing body always seemed to put anything in writing.

Eventually the junior staff member suggested FA action might be imminent. Then all went quiet again. Two more of Ward’s phone calls went unreturned. It was after yet another email that a conversati­on ensued involving Amina Graham from the FA’s legal department, who indicated that no legal action would be taken.

The FA said bringing a case before an FA commission would mean Ward being crossexami­ned again. This was no ordeal for an individual who had been through a punishing two-day tribunal, though no one at the FA seemed interested in knowing that.

When we met earlier this year, Ward flinched at the notion that she might be considered a feminist. ‘There’s a lot of stuff that you’d say is sexist in football but you’re in there and it’s part of it,’ she said. ‘I don’t think you can say, “I’m a woman so you can’t say that”. I would have been the last person to bring a claim of discrimina­tion.’

These are the reasons so many people were astonished that Glenn and Clarke had not heard of Ward when an MP brought up her case on Wednesday. Needless to say, neither of them picked up a phone to call her yesterday.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom