Daily Mail

When WILL they learn the terrible lesson of locking our children out of their schools?

- By Calvin Robinson Calvin Robinson is a school governor and former teacher

FOR secondary pupils, the announceme­nt yesterday that many schools may not open fully until after the February halfterm holiday is a cruel and deeply unnecessar­y blow.

I fear hundreds of thousands of young people will spend the rest of their lives paying for this disastrous decision, foisted on the Government by callous and opportunis­tic unions bent on exploiting the pandemic for political advantage.

As a school governor and former teacher, I am furious at the news that, while primary schools are to open after the Christmas holidays and pupils studying for GCSEs and A-levels in Years 11 and 13 will be able to return to class, the rest face weeks of more inadequate online learning.

The damage done to their progress is already catastroph­ic and probably irreparabl­e. Despite a general reopening last September, many schools have not been functionin­g fully since March. We are a long way past the point where extra homework can fill in the gaps.

A single day when classrooms are closed means more than the loss of just one day’s education. Every teacher knows that lessons are about reinforcin­g knowledge, going back over the ground already covered to make sure facts are firmly planted.

If lessons are not instilled daily, many children will slide backwards. It now looks as though, on average, secondary students are between 15 months and 22 months behind the point where we would expect them to be.

PUT plainly, 12-yearolds in Year 8 have slipped back to the level they were at when they moved up from primary school.

And in some cases, they have regressed still further. All their secondary progress has been lost. It’s unthinkabl­e, but true. And it’s not happening in just a few isolated classrooms – this is the story all over the country.

Such a statement might sound melodramat­ic. But it is based on reliable evidence from a leading assessor – Daisy Christodou­lou, who is director of education at the No More Marking project, which compares results from schools nationwide. By cross-referencin­g work submitted by teachers all over Britain, it is able to analyse children’s progress across a broad spectrum.

Of course, I recognise that the Government has to listen to scientific health advisers who are monitoring the spread of coronaviru­s. But I am frustrated beyond belief that no attention is being paid to other scientific evidence that measures the educationa­l cost of lockdown for schools and pupils.

Does anyone in the Cabinet think it’s acceptable for pupils to be 22 months behind? What do they imagine will be the outcome for this generation?

It’s so brutally unfair to load the greatest burden onto the young. We’re all suffering from the restrictio­ns – cut off from our friends and wider family, our jobs at risk, the threat of swingeing tax rises to come.

However, no one is paying a higher price than schoolchil­dren. It is not only their daily lives and friendship­s that are being turned upside down, but their whole futures.

Without education, their prospects are permanentl­y harmed. Ground is lost that can never be regained.

Inevitably, it is pupils from disadvanta­ged background­s who are worst-hit. It’s deeply unrealisti­c to imagine that children from families in the lowest economic bracket will be able to carry on learning via laptop.

Even if there were enough portable computers to go round (and believe me, there are not), many children don’t have access to reliable broadband. I know of children who have to resort to piggybacki­ng on their neighbours’ internet signal to download learning materials. In homes where, for example, there is one computer between three children of different ages, constant tensions arise over who has access and when.

Pressures are exacerbate­d when adults in the house are trying to use the wi-fi to work from home.

The cases I know about are just in London, but I’m sure the same problems are repeated in different ways across rural Britain where internet speeds are often inadequate.

Yet none of this is taken into account when the Government says blithely that pupils will have to ‘continue learning from home’. You might as well cancel the school bus and tell children that in future they can flap their arms and fly. It reveals an utter lack of practical thinking.

THE suggestion by union leaders that schools should remain closed to allow more time to prepare for Covid testing and protective measures is particular­ly mendacious. Schools up and down Britain have made exceptiona­l efforts to ensure their environmen­ts are as safe as humanly possible.

Social distancing restrictio­ns are enforced everywhere. Corridors are run on a rigid one-way system, hygiene rules are meticulous­ly enforced and battalions of cleaners have been drafted in. To pretend that another few weeks will enable these measures to be upgraded is false. They are as good as they can possibly get.

Everyone understand­s the importance of driving down infection rates and ensuring the NHS is not overloaded.

But it is also an inescapabl­e fact that young children, adolescent­s and teenagers are the least likely to be seriously affected by this virus. In the majority of cases, those with the infection won’t even know they’ve got it – they will have no symptoms and experience no illness.

Why then must they bear the brunt of Covid restrictio­ns? Why are their lives being ruined? How do we imagine that we can ever compensate them for their ruined education?

ON top of all this, the parents of pupils who cannot now return to class must be tearing their hair out in despair. I am very strongly of the opinion that teachers are not childminde­rs and schools do not exist to get children out of the house.

However, there is a practical aspect here and when classrooms are empty then millions of parents will be struggling to do their jobs. That’s very difficult for individual families, where wages may be suddenly curtailed. Moreover, it is disastrous for the national economy.

Society is a machine of complex interconne­ctions and it is currently at a standstill. Take one vital cog out of the engine and the wheels start to seize up. Make no mistake – there are militants in the teaching unions who want this to happen.

They see this as an opportunit­y to wreak social havoc and perhaps bring down the Government. This is about extremist politics and has nothing to do with education.

The children are treated as expendable pawns.

Do not blame the teachers for the actions of their unions. In most cases, they probably haven’t been consulted or offered any kind of a ballot.

Not everyone is held hostage by the unions. The headteache­rs I talk to regularly are planning to open as normal, as are many around the country. Most teachers are desperate to get back to the job they love.

It’s crucial that the Government backs them. Downing Street has to resist the urge to capitulate. Schools have to open for all our children. underminin­g their young lives is not the way to beat coronaviru­s.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom