Daily Record

Haven’t we heard it all before?

- BY PAUL HUTCHEON POLITICAL EDITOR

NICOLA Sturgeon should hope voters do not cast a ballot solely on the basis of her Government’s domestic record.

In 2016, two years into the job as first minister, Sturgeon cited education as her No1 priority.

The goal of the SNP, she said, would be to “substantia­lly close” the attainment gap in the next parliament.

This was the correct decision. Inequaliti­es in school outcomes shame our country and result in children from poorer areas earning less and living shorter lives.

By any objective yardstick, the gap has not closed “substantia­lly” and the life chances of pupils are still largely determined by postcode.

The SNP manifesto launch by Sturgeon yesterday promised to invest £1billion to “close the school attainment gap”. Cue a strong sense of deja vu. On the health service, a promise to invest an extra £2.5billion over the next term will be welcomed by patients and staff but the Government’s record on the NHS has been patchy.

According to Scottish Labour, the SNP missed their Treatment Time Guarantee for patients nearly 400,000 times.

Extra investment in the NHS is essential but a significan­t amount of this new money will have to be spent on curing problems that built up before Covid struck and worsened.

The SNP manifesto contains a range of welcome commitment­s, such as no NHS dental charges, doubling the Scottish Child Payment, tackling climate change and charting a different course on a range of areas to the UK Government.

But on key bread-andbutter policies, there has been a delivery deficit that spans the administra­tions of Salmond and Sturgeon.

On poverty, any Government serious about wanting to reduce inequality would put council tax abolition at the top of their list.

In 2007, the SNP promised to scrap the council tax. At yesterday’s launch, 14 years later, Sturgeon vaguely promised a “Citizens’ Assembly” would “consider the way forward”.

Legitimate questions will also be asked about how a re-elected SNP Government will find the money for the public spending rises.

At some point, the UK and Scottish Government­s will be presented with a bill marked “Covid” and it should be those with broadest shoulders who are asked to cough up.

However, the SNP manifesto does not back income tax rises for the rich and even supports a reduction in the Large Business Supplement.

These shortcomin­gs will ultimately have no bearing on an election that may result in an SNP majority.

The country is split on the constituti­on.

With support for independen­ce running at 50 per cent at least, Sturgeon’s party can rely on the backing of about half the population who will vote.

This perhaps explains why Sturgeon was so relaxed when she ran through the contents of the SNP manifesto.

The result is almost a foregone conclusion, but voters should still expect the gap between promise and delivery.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom