Evening Telegraph (First Edition)
Trust claims digital advertising could ‘cheapen heritage’
PLACING digital advertising boards outside Caird Hall could cheapen the city’s heritage, it has been claimed.
Dundee Civic Trust fears the planned £140,500 council project could make City Square look like a poor man’s Times Square in New York.
Two advertising screens would be set up at the building’s front steps, as well as another outside The McManus, if councillors pass the plans next week.
An illuminated sign installed on the south side of the Caird Hall would also promote the venue.
Donald Gordon, of Dundee Civic Trust, said he feels uneasy about the plan.
“We are not Times Square. In fact, we are better than that. It will need to be very upmarket so as not to harm the look of the area,” he said.
“The Caird Hall has a distinguished frontage and we can’t see that ruined.”
Under the plans, £107,500 will be spent on the advertising boards while £33,000 will go to the Caird Hall signage.
The council said the A-listed building needs to be “enhanced” to tie in with the Waterfront development.
The new 500mm-high cast bronze letters will be positioned on the south façade facing the River Tay.
Mr Gordon said: “£140,000 is a lot of money. Is it necessary?
“Is it appropriate to spend this when other essential council services have to be cut?”
“They must expect to make quite a lot of money in advertising.
“I’m also worried about the kind of advertising we would see. When I think of these boards in shopping centres I picture them saying ‘chips always available’.”
Councillors will vote on the plans at the city development committee on Monday.
Convener Mark Flynn said the move is a positive one.
He said: “With the development of the Waterfront and the prominent position the Caird Hall has overlooking Slessor Gardens, a back-lit bronze sign announcing the venue would be a fitting addition to the streetscape.
“We want to be in a position to have the city centre at its best when it is safe again for visitors to come to Dundee.”
Plans for an advertising screen and a 32-inch interactive touchscreen on South Marketgait near the Overgate Shopping Centre were recently rejected.
Planning officers said the move would have a “detrimental visual impact” on the surrounding area.
The plan was submitted by Infocus Public Networks Ltd, part of multi-national the JCDecaux group.
It claims to be the world’s leading provider of billboard advertising and hopes to establish 16 of the screens across Dundee.
The decision will be reviewed by councillors on Tuesday.