“We can learn from the gaming industry in terms of making mental health treatment more appealing”
Could virtual reality be useful in treating anxiety disorders? Psychologists led by Prof Daniel Freeman of Oxford University are using VR to help people overcome their fear of heights
What causes a fear of heights?
Some people really overestimate the danger: they think they’re going to fall, throw themselves off (‘the call of the void’) or that a building might collapse. That causes anxiety, it causes people to avoid heights and it can impact on day-to-day life: they can’t walk or drive across bridges, or go to meetings high-up in office blocks. About 1 in 20 people have it at the level of phobia, when you’ve had it for at least six months. Vertigo is something different, a balance issue.
Why treat it with virtual reality?
There are some good psychological treatments for mental health problems and if you see a skilled therapist, you can do really well. But it can be hard to find a therapist, so we’re trying to help people via automated virtual reality. The fear of heights programme was our first test.
What did the treatment involve?
People came to the offices of [university spinout company] Oxford VR. We screened them for at least a moderate fear of heights and had 49 randomised to the VR treatment and 51 to the control condition. They received the treatment, which consisted of about five VR sessions of 30 minutes each, over the course of two weeks.
In the VR package we’ve been using, you meet the therapist, who’s called Nick, in a virtual office. She explains what causes a fear of heights and how to overcome it, then takes you into the atrium of an office block and asks, “Which of the 10 floors do you want to start off with?”. You go up to whichever floor you selected and carry out a range of tasks: it might be just standing by the edge, rescuing a cat from a tree, or traversing a rickety walkway. In this way you can learn that your fears are inaccurate and misguiding your behaviour, because actually nothing bad happens.
How did you measure improvement?
It’s a series of questions on clinical assessments – all these questionnaires are validated against performance at real heights. People’s fears came down on average by two-thirds, and 69 per cent no longer met the trial entry criteria. It’s not a direct comparison, but compared to other trials that use face-to-face therapy, the effects are almost double. I was surprised the results were even better than expected. There’s no reason why it shouldn’t help people with a milder fear of heights.
One of the beautiful things about VR is you know it’s not real, so you try things you would never do. Then when you come up against much more mundane heights in day-to-day life, you have the confidence that you can deal with it.
When will VR treatments be available?
Over the next couple of months, we’re piloting this treatment in NHS psychological services, putting the VR kit into clinics. In future years, people could do the treatments at home, but at the moment they don’t have the equipment.
Oxford VR is employing people from the games industry to make these sorts of treatments much more fun and engaging. We think we can learn a lot from the computer games industry in terms of making mental health treatment much more appealing to people.
ABOVE: Fear of heights is common, and can impact on people’s lives if it develops into a phobia
BELOW: Oxford University’s virtual reality application lets people carry out a range of tasks at different heights, without any risk