Grammar schools might create elitism in teen girls
A STUDY has revealed that grammar schools may create a sense of hierarchy and elitism among teenage girls.
Researchers at Loughborough University found that some girls in an elite non fee-paying grammar school viewed poverty as a moral failing and associated it with belonging to other groups and pupils at other schools.
As part of the study, students aged 13-14 were interviewed at a UK grammar school to examine how they understand and perceive class, gender, ethnicity, race and religion.
Researchers argue that girls in these schools are likely to transition to top universities and go on to hold powerful positions in the future – but there has been little research into these elite spaces.
The study found that while the school was ethnically and religiously diverse, it had little diversity from students with different income levels and social backgrounds.
A number of girls viewed areas with high levels of poverty as ‘dodgy and dangerous’ and associated social class differences with people who were at other schools.
Researchers argue that this is an example of how grammar schools can be elite spaces because middle class parents often have the ability to pay for private primary education or tuition, to make sure their child can pass the entry exams to get into grammar school.
Some families even move home to be within the grammar school catchment areas to strategically gain access to the education.
The research, which has been published in scientific journal Geoforum, discovered that girls classed diversity as ethnic, religious or racial and they welcomed the differences between them, with some saying it made them more open and at ease with each other.
Pupils said their school was an opportunity for them to interact with other girls who were from different ethnic backgrounds and it enabled them to broaden their minds.
One of the paper’s authors, Louise Holt, head of Geography and Environment at Loughborough University, said: “Given the powerful positions these girls are likely to occupy in top professions, how they understand and perform class, gender, ethnicity/ race and religion is crucial.
“Little attention has been paid to investments of middle class parents in equipping and sending their children, often over relatively large geographical distances to selective state schools.
“Grammar schools are intriguing elite spaces that are positioned between the state comprehensives and elite fee paying schools, that have been the subject of recent scholarship.
“It is evident that these engaging, hard-working and kind girls were, for the most part, unaware of both the scaffolding which had supported their entry into grammar school and the inequalities that this perpetuates.”