Business Focus: Tower servers
Dave Mitchell advises what to look for when choosing a tower server, and subjects four options to real-world testing
Dave Mitchell advises how to choose a tower server, and reviews four likely options.
Cloud services may be all the rage, but the traditional tower server still has a key role to play. Running essential services in-house brings advantages in terms of data security, performance and availability – and getting set up doesn’t have to be expensive, with entry-level models starting at under £600.
Space-saving designs allow these compact servers to fit into the smallest of office environments, and the latest models have enough power on tap to handle the most demanding small business’ applications. They’re ideal for growing micro-businesses looking to upgrade their legacy PC-based networks with a purpose-built server. They can also be a good choice for larger businesses that need to deploy on-site IT services to staff in remote or branch offices.
This month, we test-drive four entry-level tower servers, each with the power and flexibility to handle all of your on-premises IT requirements. We review their features and put them through their paces in the lab to help you make the right buying decision.
Unless you to plan to run heavy-duty business applications (such as huge databases), a server with a single CPU socket will be easily up to the job. As to which model, we recommend Intel’s Xeon E3-1200 series – and the suppliers of this month’s review systems evidently agree, as all of them chose processors from the latest Xeon E3-1200 v6 range.
The family comprises eight models, with clock speeds ranging from 3GHz up to 3.9GHz. It might be tempting to go for the fastest variant, but that’s probably overkill: the entry-level E3-1220 v6 is perfectly adequate for a typical small business, and stepping up to the top-end E3-1280 v6 will add around £500 to your shopping bill.
All CPU models have four cores, but for processor-intensive tasks, choose a model that supports Intel’s Hyper-Threading technology, as this allows it to process eight tasks at once. Avoid the models whose model numbers end in “-5” – these are aimed at workstation roles, and come with embedded Intel P630 HD graphics chips that you don’t need to pay for.
If your budget is tight, you can save money by choosing an older E3-1200 v5 model – this will still be more than powerful enough for a typical small business server, but you’ll be missing out on support for faster 2,400MHz DDR4 memory. The v6 models are also more power-efficient, which will have a small impact on your energy bills.
Power and noise
Even entry-level towers are designed for always-on business use, and have
features you won’t find in most PCs. Manufacturers focus on minimising power usage, and you’ll see a choice of power supply units (PSUs) with ratings ranging from 80 Plus Gold to Platinum. These indicate how efficient the PSU is at converting AC to DC, with Platinum models delivering the highest 92% efficiency. A high rating translates to lower power usage, less heat generation and hence less fan noise, so choose the best you can afford.
System designers also pay a lot of attention to internal air flow, which again helps tower servers run cool without the need for large, noisy fans. To measure noise levels, we use the excellent SPLnFFT Noise Meter iOS app, which is available for only £3.99 from the App Store.
All of the servers we tested this month impressed us with their quietness, with noise levels ranging from 35.5dB up to 38.7dB. These measurements are so low, it’s safe to say none will be noticeable in the average office environment.
We advise against locating your new server on the floor or under a desk, as it’ll suck up all sorts of grot, including carpet fibres. If you have no option, make sure you clean the fans, drive bays and CPU heatsink every few months, otherwise there’s a real risk that your server will clog up, overheat and eventually fail – with catastrophic results.
An in-house server can be a very useful central data store, offering more space and faster access than a cloud service. Think ahead when choosing hard disks for your server and ensure there’s plenty of headroom for future demand. Large-form-factor (LFF) SATA drives represent the best value as they’re getting increasingly cheap and are now available in sizes up to 10TB.
Remember to factor in storage requirements for your operating system, too: both Windows Server 2012 R2 with a GUI and Server 2016 with the Desktop Experience require around 40GB. Your business applications will quickly eat up space, too. To avoid problems down the line, we recommend a minimum of 1TB for your system drive.
For increased operating system and app performance, consider using solid-state disks for your boot drive. Choices range from SATA drives, which can be used as drop-in replacements for regular LFF disks, to high-performance NVMe M.2 SSDs – check out our latest SSD group test in issue 275 for more details.
“All of this might sound like a lot to consider, but selecting your first tower server really needn’t be a daunting task”
Protect and serve
Choosing a server with room for three or four hard disks allows critical data to be protected with a RAID array. A RAID1 mirror is fine for protecting a single drive; if you’re using three or more disks then RAID5 is more versatile, as you can easily add extra drives to the array when you want to increase capacity.
All four review servers come with embedded RAID controllers on their motherboards. Whether it’s Dell’s PERC S130, HPE’s Smart Array B140i or Intel’s C236 chip, they all support mirrors and RAID5 out of the box, which should be all a small business needs. The only caveat is if you want to uses SAS drives: these provide greater storage performance and lower failure rates than SATA models, but they’re much more expensive, and few entry-level servers support them as standard, so you may need to budget for a standalone SAS controller card.
Also decide whether you need hot-swap hard disks. Cold-swap systems are cheaper, but require you to take the system offline to perform disk maintenance. If you need your server to keep running while you’re replacing or upgrading the disks in a RAID array, then choose hot-swap.
All of this might sound like a lot to consider, but selecting your first tower server really needn’t be a daunting task. The four models we’ve tried this month provide everything you need to get started. We’ve chosen them to fit the smallest of budgets, but also to provide a good combination of capacity, power and expandability: read on to see which is the best fit for your growing business.
BELOW Server and OS remote control are valuable support tools but may be offered as optional extras
ABOVE Dell’s iDRAC8 management chip even tells you what’s happening on the front of the server
LEFT Fujitsu’s very handy System Monitor runs on the server and includes email fault alerting