Scottish Daily Mail

Reports of their death are greatly exaggerate­d, so don’t write off the Lazarus Lib Dems

-

Istumbled across Nick Clegg recently – almost literally, as it happens – signing copies of his autobiogra­phy in a corner of a regional Waterstone­s. there was a decent turnout, and Clegg looked fit and well.

He was dressed down in that preppy english privately educated way – suede boots, neatly ironed jeans, shirt and V-neck, sports jacket. He’s a handsome lad with an easy, chilled manner – now layered with the world-weary authority and gallows humour you often find in ex-somebodies.

If he seems older and wiser, he conversely seems younger and fresher too, freed from the depredatio­ns of government and the Cabinet table snipings and media-shaftings from those Right-wing tories who could never reconcile themselves to the existence of the Coalition.

It might be a surprise to hear of the former lib dem leader’s relaxed demeanour. After all, the reward for five years governing with the Conservati­ves to ensure democratic stability at a time of severe economic crisis was abject humiliatio­n: his party was reduced to a stubby rump of eight mPs in the 2015 general election, with big hitters such as danny Alexander, Vince Cable and ed davey cast into the wilderness to do whatever it is ex-lib dem mPs do.

thus disempower­ed, this most europhile of parties then had to stand on the sidelines and watch as david Cameron called and lost a referendum on the country’s eu membership.

Now brexit is upon us, and a steelier tory administra­tion has emerged to send into exile the centrist politics in which Clegg and Cameron believed, and which dominated british government and politics for the past 20 years.

SO what gives? Perhaps chirpy Clegg, now a humble mP, has simply become aware earlier than most of one evolving truth: the lib dems, despite what many of us thought, are not necessaril­y done for. they have not kicked the bucket, run down the curtain or joined the bleedin’ choir invisible.

And for this they have Cameron and his disastrous referendum to thank.

Clegg and co may justifiabl­y view brexit as a calamity, but as the old political truism has it, every crisis contains an opportunit­y. And as Alex salmond is fond of saying, you must play the ball as it lies.

under the radar, even before June’s referendum, the party picked up 45 new seats in may’s english local government elections, while labour lost 18 and the tories 48. It was the only party to gain control of a council.

but the result of thursday’s byelection in Witney to replace the departing Cameron gives cause for measured optimism on the national stage, and hints at that aforementi­oned brexit dividend.

though the tories retained the seat, their 2015 majority was cut by 20,000 votes to 5,700 and the lib dems vaulted from fourth place to second, taking 30 per cent of the votes cast. labour was pushed into third, and ukip slumped to fifth, behind the Greens.

One must never read too much into one by-election, of course, but there is a certain logic to this outcome: errant tories, wooed by brexit and theresa may’s nonmetropo­litan traditiona­lism, are returning from ukip to the mothership; labour voters disillusio­ned by the hopelessne­ss of Corbynism are looking afresh at the lib dems, as are disillusio­ned Remainers and floating centrists.

Next up, a possible by-election in Richmond Park and North Kingston, where Conservati­ve mP Zac Goldsmith is threatenin­g to quit if the government supports a new runway at Heathrow.

there is a strong chance in that event that the lib dems will take the seat, which they held until relatively recently – they will, as acknowledg­ed masters of byelection strategy, throw everything at it and certainly come close.

before we get over-excited, a national YouGov poll published yesterday put the party at just 8 per cent, with ukip on 12 per cent, labour on 26 per cent and the tories way out in front on 42 per cent.

A lot of damage has been done to the lib dem brand and it will not be easily fixed. It is not clear that the party is in much condition to mount a revival, or that its current leader tim Farron should be seen as more than a likeable lightweigh­t.

but, as we know, success in politics begets success. People are attracted to momentum: it has a habit of changing both narratives and perception­s. And the electoral experts detect stirrings.

Rob Ford, Professor of Political science at the university of manchester and one of the country’s leading psephologi­sts, says: ‘such is the depth of their decline that it will probably take two elections to come back.’

but they could spring some surprises in traditiona­l areas of strength such as south-West england, as Willie Rennie already did in northern scotland.

they’ll also benefit from being the only viable Remain voice in many middle england seats, and the ukip collapse means they’re the only viable opposition to the Conservati­ves in many seats.’

brexit has gone off like a nuclear bomb in british politics. the debate, four months on from the vote, remains heavily emotional on all sides.

the path ahead is far from clear. On the electoral and policy side, no one really knows what the longterm consequenc­es will be, though there is a serious prospect of a sizeable realignmen­t of loyalties.

the gracelessn­ess in victory of the may government’s more robust ministers and their allies is making it difficult for the wounds opened by the referendum campaign to heal.

THe administra­tion ploughs mulishly towards the hardest of brexits, adopting a confrontat­ional posture towards the referendum losers, apparently forgetting they comprise almost half the electorate. low emotional intelligen­ce is rarely a good sign in government­s.

brexit also seems likely to serve as something of a ground zero. such is its epochal import that much of what has gone before could be wiped away – clean slates and fresh starts and all that.

the lib dems have long been dogged by their (entirely sensible) u-turn on tuition fees, but it surely now seems a bit pre-war to continue holding that against them. And where that spell in coalition government counted against them in the short–term, it may play to their advantage over a longer period. After all, they didn’t screw up in power.

Quite the opposite: their ministers competentl­y delivered a decent number of social democratic policy wins, such as taking the lowest earners out of income tax, ensuring extra money was spent on the most disadvanta­ged schoolchil­dren and keeping the government focused on the environmen­t. the idea that the party is unfit for office has been debunked.

lastly, there is no sign of the new unifying party of the centre-ground that many of us had hoped to see. labour’s anti-Corbyn mPs are simply too tribal to give up on their grim old institutio­n or to accept they have been vanquished from its power centres for good by the Hard left.

that leaves those voters who might have been tempted by a new version of the sdP scanning around for a champion.

Will their gaze come to rest on the lib dems? It’s not unthinkabl­e. In a way, what other option is there?

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom