Are hip replacements such a bad experience?

I AM sorry that Bel Mooney’s hip replacement experience was not a good one (Good Health), but not everyone’s is the same. I had a hip replaced seven weeks ago and, while no picnic, it was a vast improvement on the pain I had before. After discharge, a friend stayed with me for the first five nights, but I was soon able largely to look after myself. Night-time was the worst, but strategically placed pillows helped. At first, getting in and out of bed was painful, but not difficult with a leg lifter. Exercises are crucial. I’d given up crutches and a walking stick by week five. I’m 64, but know of two ladies in their 80s who had similar positive experiences. Don’t let Bel’s story put you off: it’s major surgery, but golly, it’s worth it! Mrs Annie glibbery, broadway, somerset.

I was disappointed to read Bel’s article, as I’m sure it will put people off a necessary operation. I had my hip replaced four years ago, at 63, almost unable to walk from bone spurs and osteoarthritis. I expected to come out of hospital a new woman, and I did. you are stiff after, but the way to ease that is to walk and do exercises. Sitting was most painful, as staples closing the wound jabbed in. after a few days, I sent my partner back to work, as I could dress, climb stairs and shower by myself. I went to hip circuit training physio after six weeks. and, after three months, I walked five miles of the Pembrokeshire Coast Path. I am sure mine is a more usual outcome.

Tricia Fleming, stotfold, beds.

DID Bel’s downbeat account serve any good purpose? Those who are soon to have this operation, myself included, would surely prefer to read a more cheerful article. Janet Wild, ilfracombe, devon.