Scottish Daily Mail

A weighty debate in this Big Brother format? Fat chance!

- CHRISTOPHE­R STEVENS

Everyone is searching f rantically f or new ways of being offended these days. But a loudmouthe­d activist called victoria took her hurt feelings to a new height of self- i ndulgence, on t he discussion show Who Are You

Calling Fat? (BBC2).

Steaming from the ears, she insisted the term ‘obese’ and ‘overweight’ should never be printed in full. The self-proclaimed ‘ body positive’ therapist labelled them ‘the o-words’ and declared they were too offensive to be written without asterisks.

Anything’s offensive if you try hard enough. Pretty soon, if the l i kes of victoria get their way, the f olk of north Piddle in Worcesters­hire will have to use a bleeper when they spell out their addresses.

When BBC execs sent nine largert han- average people to l i ve together, some of them morbidly o- word and others j ust wellcovere­d, they were hoping to churn up lots of confrontat­ions, tearful recriminat­ions, insults and meltdowns. They weren’t disappoint­ed.

This is television’s new favourite format for addressing controvers­ial topics. Studio debates and audience questions are seen as an outmoded way to stage discussion­s.

now, everyone piles into a house to be filmed as tempers fray. It used to be called Big Brother but these days, as the housemates sneak into the garden for a gossip or blub with self-pity in the kitchen, we’re expected to take their conversati­ons seriously.

It was hard to give any credence to their arguments when half the household decided to ‘ challenge stereotype­s’ by standing in the middle of a shopping precinct in their swimming costumes and inviting passers-by to write inspiratio­nal messages on their bodies.

The show took a grim turn when f ormer nightclub owner Colin dropped in to show off his prosthetic leg. He had an amputation after years of Type 2 diabetes: he broke a bone i n his foot and gangrene set in.

once a big eater, smoker and heavy drinker, Colin was so unhealthy that his surgeon feared he wouldn’t survive a general anaestheti­c — so the limb was removed while he was fully conscious, with just local pain relief.

you’d think a horror story like that would make anyone look at lettuce in a new light, but three of the housemates dismissed it as scaremonge­ring and ‘ body shaming’. At that point, it was hard to sustain much sympathy.

There was one great gag, though, from stand-up comedian Jed, a big lad himself: ‘I could go to the doctor with a bullet wound, and he’d say: “It’s because you’re fat... if you were skinny, they probably would have missed you!”’

A brisk walk and some mountain air would be any doctor’s advice for the ov*rwe*ght, and The Mountain (ITv) supplied plenty of that.

This four-part series offers a look at Snowdon across the four seasons, through the eyes of farmers, mountain rescuers, railway workers and Alwena, the lovely lady who runs the cafe halfway up the mountainsi­de.

Some of the l ocals f ound perpetual awe in their surroundin­gs. Poet viv loved to swim in the clear mountain lakes, where the water was so cold she could feel it in her marrowbone.

others, such as sheep farmer Joe, were more blasé. He’d never been to the summit i tself: ‘What’s the point when you see it every day?’

More t han half a million visitors a year would disagree with him. Mind you, a lot of them probably get no further than Alwena’s cafe.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom