Hate Crime Bill still f lawed, Yousaf warned

THE SNP’s controversial Hate Crime Bill continues to threaten freedom of speech despite ministers seeking to change large parts of the legislation, it has been claimed.

Justice Secretary Humza Yousaf was yesterday warned that further changes will be required as MSPs voted to pass the general principles of the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill.

Mr Yousaf said he would keep an ‘open mind’ over amendments brought forward in Stage 2 of the legislative process – as opponents raised serious concerns over the impact the Bill will have.

Holyrood’s justice committee said the Bill should only be approved if additional amendments are made.

Mr Yousaf promised further changes after the committee’s report, but convener Adam Tomkins said: ‘ We do need to go further to ensure the Bill achieves its objectives without interfering with our fundamental rights.’

Fellow Tory MSP Liam Kerr also demanded further concessions – as the Conservatives voted against the general principles of the legislation.

Mr Kerr told Holyrood: ‘This Bill is the most controversial in the history of devolution. But the Cabinet Secretary’s response has not reflected the avalanche of opposition this Bill has faced.

‘Genuine hate crime must always be punished but this law goes too far. Our fundamental right to freedom of speech remains under threat.’ On Monday, Mr Yousaf pledged there would be a strengthening of the protection for freedom of expression in the legislation.

But this was ‘arguably not sufficient’, Mr Kerr insisted.

Labour MSP Rhoda Grant said the Justice Secretary ‘must go further to meet the concerns expressed’.

Proposals for offences of ‘stirring up hatred’ in the legislation have attracted a slew of criticism, with concerns raised that they could stifle freedom of expression.

Mr Yousaf said the Scottish Government had already shown ‘ great willingness to compromise’ as he pledged: ‘I will continue to have an open mind on amendments.’