Scottish Daily Mail

Doctor dubbed ‘God’ is guilty of failures

- By James Tozer

A TOP oncologist nicknamed ‘god’ by grateful patients was facing career ruin yesterday after a tribunal found he had given inappropri­ate treatment to a string of terminally-ill cancer patients.

Professor Justin stebbing, who has treated stars including ‘oxo Mum’ actress Lynda Bellingham and sir Michael Parkinson, was dubbed ‘Dr Hope’ for treating patients who had been told they were beyond help.

But during a marathon disciplina­ry hearing set up after a whistleblo­wer raised concerns over his private practice, the 50-year-old admitted to a litany of failures relating to 12 patients.

Yesterday a tribunal panel found the oxfordeduc­ated doctor guilty of three remaining allegation­s of failing to provide good clinical care, with another three not fully proved.

It means a total of 33 out of 36 counts he faced have now formally been found proved.

The outcome will cause serious damage to his reputation and send shockwaves through the UK oncology community and the wider medical world. stebbing is a professor of cancer medicine and oncology at imperial College and had a lucrative private practice in Harley street.

But after concerns were raised over his work at top London clinic, Leaders in oncology Care, an anonymous whistleblo­wer sent a dossier to the general Medical Council in 2017.

A Medical Practition­ers Tribunal service hear

‘Maximising their quality of life’

ing that began in January last year was told he faced allegation­s including providing inappropri­ate medication to keep terminally ill patients alive and giving them ‘unrealisti­c expectatio­ns’ in circumstan­ces of ‘near futility’.

The tribunal heard how he told the daughter of one dying patient that her father was a ‘very sick bunny’ but that he was ‘going to get him a lot better’. When he died a month later, his daughter asked him about the comment.

stebbing was said to have shrugged and told her that 40 per cent of his patients died.

When another member of staff questioned the treatment that patient was being given, he was said to have told her: ‘He is f***ed anyway so whether we give it or don’t, he will die.’

other charges admitted or found proved concerned his failure to gain informed consent by not discussing the risks and benefits of treatment with patients, and failing to maintain proper records.

giving evidence, stebbing said his private patients were ‘typically highly motivated to maximise their survival and quality of life’, although he admitted he was not very good at giving a ‘very accurate’ prognosis.

While major private healthcare firms, including HCa, suspended stebbing from their list of consultant­s, he faced no accusation­s that his actions were financiall­y motivated.

The panel is expected to give the reasons for its findings today. it will now decide if stebbing’s fitness to practice has been impaired and what sanctions, if any, he will face. This could include striking him off the medical register.

Last night his solicitor, Michael Ryan, said it would be ‘inappropri­ate’ for his client to comment further at this stage of the proceeding­s.

stebbing continues to do ‘a small amount of clinical work’ under supervisio­n at imperial College, a spokesman said.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom