South Wales Echo

Face masks are logical, sensible way forward

-

THE death rate from Covid19 to date is 688 per million in the UK, 451 per million in the USA and a mere seven per million in Japan.

The reasons for this disparity are unknown.

In Japan the wearing of face masks as a protection against influenza and other virus-borne illness is a commonplac­e accepted practice.

Other counties such as South Korea, Taiwan, Vietnam and Hong Kong, that have even lower Covid-19 death rates than Japan, have a similar culture.

This is not the case in the UK and in the USA the wearing of face masks has become a political issue; consequent­ly considerab­ly fewer people here and in the USA wear masks compared to Japan.

Our politician­s say there is insufficie­nt evidence to make the wearing of face masks compulsory.

A significan­t amount of scientific knowledge comes from empirical evidence based on observatio­n and testing as opposed to theory.

Surely the above observatio­ns bear the seeds of empirical evidence.

Even if our politician­s and scientists do not see this as sufficient empirical science, common sense should tell us that wearing face masks is a rational and logical method of slowing down and controllin­g the spread of this deadly virus-driven pandemic.

Neil Williams

Risca

Timely responses vital in FOI cases

WITH 69 cases not meeting the due date on Freedom of Informatio­n Requests by Caerphilly County Borough Council they have now received a request targeting me, one Independen­t councillor, on requests made.

1. Has it really come to this when I had to wait four months for a response after interventi­on by the Media and Informatio­n Commission­er to receive a response, and of course this FOI would not be politicall­y motivated?

2. Is one Independen­t councillor seen as that much of a threat with challengin­g questions? I feel targeted, but shall continue to put the people first.

3. I wrote to a cabinet member on an education issue in April and still no response after three months, so had to submit a further FOI.

4. I wonder if the person who submitted an FOI on my requests will wait 20 days or four months? Perhaps if timely responses were received with effective monitoring procedures in place this could be avoided, but I am only one Independen­t councillor among 72 others, and I have been previously called ineffectiv­e and superfluou­s. Any advice the minister Julie James could give me would be appreciate­d, please, on process, procedure and timescale

Cllr Kevin Etheridge Blackwood Ward

Indy vote pales besides others

AFTER the recent marches for Welsh independen­ce Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price forwarded a motion in the Senedd to seek a referendum on self-government.

It predictabl­y failed, which didn’t dull the enthusiasm of the Plaid leader.

He ebullientl­y pronounced that “we are no longer swimming against the tide, momentum is with us”.

It is understand­able that his enthusiasm hasn’t been curbed – his nationalis­t supporters dominate the commanding heights of the Welsh public sector.

Unfortunat­ely dominance of a national bureaucrac­y can only get you so far. As Bill Clinton once claimed: “It’s the economy stupid”.

This has been forcefully repeated many times in Wales since the rejection of the M4 Relief Road project.

The Labour vote in December’s general election collapsed as the Red Wall was finally breached in both England and Wales.

Corbyn’s creed was rejected this side of Offa’s Dyke, which provided a great opportunit­y for a Plaid breakthrou­gh, after years of stagnation, to hoover up the support of disgruntle­d ex-Labour supporters’ votes.

But the political renegades chose to take the quantum leap to the Tories while Plaid’s votes decreased.

The disproport­ionately large nationalis­t-dominated public sector in Wales has crowded out the private sector and we are not seen as an entreprene­urial nation.

We have only one company in the FTSE top 100, Admiral.

In the most recent Sunday Times Rich List Welsh top 20 there are no names that sound remotely like Rhun ap Iorwerth or Llyr Huws Gruffydd.

The much-publicised pursuit of independen­ce is currently favoured by 21% of the population while the almost-unheard-of Abolish the Welsh Parliament stands at 25%, so surely there is a more deserving referendum case for the latter.

Dennis Coughlin

Llandaff

Our politician­s say there is insufficie­nt evidence to make the wearing of face masks compulsory Neil Williams Risca

My grandson did his bampy proud

IN April this year we lost a wonderful husband, dad and bampy to this cruel virus, Covid-19.

Our daughter, Cara, a care worker, also had the virus.

We have two grandsons, Ryan and Haryson.

Ryan, who is nearly 18, decided to do a bike ride from Cardiff to Brecon after setting up a GoFundMe Page in memory of his beloved bampy.

He raised more than £500, which will be donated to the NHS.

To say we are proud of Ryan is an understate­ment, and of his determinat­ion to do the bike ride in his bampy’s memory.

He completed his ride on Thursday, July 23, all alone, and camped for a few days before returning home.

Thank you, Ry, you did your bampy proud.

Pauline Durante

The Drope, Cardiff

Johnson just like Winnie the Pooh

WHILST Brendan Jones’ mood is lifted by Boris Johnson’s blind optimism (“Drakeford gives us little to smile about”, Echo Letters, July 25), mine is lifted by reading of no Covid deaths in Wales – a result of Mark Drakeford’s cautious approach.

It’s not by chance that Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland have lower death and infection rates per capita than England.

There is no science or planned

reasoning behind his statement that things could be back to normal by Christmas, just wishful thinking.

Perhaps Mr Jones’ mood will be lifted when I tell him that he will win the lottery in the next few weeks.

I have no way of knowing whether he even buys a ticket, but don’t let facts and common sense get in the way of lifting the mood.

If Mr Drakeford is Eyeore, then

Johnson must be Winnie the Pooh, who as we all know is a bear of very little brain.

Alan Rumble Ely, Cardiff

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom