Concerns over plans for ‘Victorian’ pavilion
I would like to reply to your article in last Friday’s Stirling Observer (February 16, 2018) pertaining to the proposal by Tom Jones for the erection of a Victorian-style pavilion in Ancaster Square, Callander.
Mr Jones believes this project is necessary on the grounds it could be used to shelter from the rain those taking part in or watching performances of music and dancing by groups such as Callander Pipe Band, Callander Brass, Liz Campbell’s School of Dancing, etc.
I have great concerns regarding this proposal and manner in which it is being pursued as Mr Jones claims there is a degree of public support for it but offers no evidence to back this up.
The proposal suggests little understanding of Callander’s history, design and architecture.
It appears to be of Victorian design and , I would imagine, aims to blend in with the existing centre.
If it was a restoration project then fine - but it is not.
Any new structure creates an opportunity to build using new ideas, materials and techniques and there are some spectacular examples to be seen: the stunning pyramid in front of the Louvre in Paris; new V & A Design Museum in Dundee, and the Scottish Parliament building at Holyrood.
Other readers have used our social media page to comment on the Ancaster Square plans.
Rosalind Boyd said:“Personally I think it’s ugly and hides the beautiful church building behind it. I have noticed people set up stalls there. Perhaps the council are looking to sell the space to vendors? On a sunny day this open space is
Visit any city in the world and you will see some astonishing new buildings that are the mark of human ingenuity and desire to progress ideals in art, design and architecture for today’s and future generations.
Mr Jones is a very determined man to the point that it is imperative that the people of Callander do not sleepwalk into a situation not of their own making.
If some weather protection is indeed necessary then he needs to tailor the proposal to what is reasonable and practicable.
Maybe a form of
lovely. Definite no from me.”
Bryan Grieve:“Great public space with tables and chairs in the summer, also public events.”
Ingrid Maclean:“It’s hideous. Why spoil the look of the square and St Kessogs as was.”
David John Burgess:“Why don’t they put solar panels on the roof?”
Lorna Macnair:“Would spoil the temporary awning that is financially viable and can be erected and dismantled, might be the answer.
However, no matter what, there has to be proper public consultation with the whole of the Callander community.
Gordon T Scott, Main Street, Callander
view of the beautiful church.”
Karen Drummond:“Who comes up with these money-wasting ideas? That would look awful. It looks like a bus station.”
Pam Wilson:“Looks like it’s a big market stall. Wonder if the locals have been consulted. I’m sure they would have a view of where the money would be better spent.”