Tribunal hears appeals against call up

Three cases were heard by Dunblane Burgh recruitment tribunal 100 years ago.

Alex Henderson, High Street, Dunblane, appealed against call-up on behalf of George Blair, a 44-yearold watch and clock repairer who had been classed grade one in terms of his fitness for military service.

Tribunal members were told that if Mr Blair was called up the business would have to close as it would be impossible to find a skilled substitute. However, the national service representative said watchmaking was not considered a work of national importance and the tribunal agreed.

The appeal for exemption was dismissed.

In the second case, Robert Holliday, a 45-year-old gardener, classed grade two, was the subject of an appeal by his employer Dr Lindsay.

It was stated that from 1914 to 1917, he acted as chauffeur and gardener but was now engaged in food production.

He looked after Dr Lindsay’s garden and those of two others, and assisted occasionally on a farm at Sheriffmuir.

However, the national service representative said there was insufficient work for one man looking after the gardens and the appeal was dismissed.

Dunblane Co-operative Society appealed on behalf of their manager Andrew Calder, claiming it was in the national interest that he remain at the helm.

He was 40, classed C3 and it was argued he would be of greater service to the country by staying in his position.

A medical certificate was submitted stating Mr Calder was “unfit for any branch of His Majesty’s Army”.

His case was continued.