Common thread
Sir, I read with interest the headlines in the Arran Banner last week regarding the cancelled ferries and the generosity of islanders in helping stranded passengers. That generosity comes as no surprise to me as someone who has visited the island many times, in all seasons over the years.
What also comes as no surprise is that inclement weather brings cancelled ferries. While I appreciate that the master of the ferry must make a decision whether to sail or not, I wonder if anyone has analysed the reasons for the decision not to sail. For example, is the sea so rough that the safety of the boat could be compromised on the crossing or is it difficulty in entering Ardrossan Harbour that causes the cancellations?
From my own experience over the years, difficulty entering Ardrossan has been stated many times as a reason for the cessation of ferry services – no surprise really to a layman given the direction of waves at the harbour entrance, the tight approach channel and the fact that the ferry must make a near 90-degree turn to access the vehicle ramps. I know that the argument over alternative ferry facilities at Troon has already been aired but I wonder why there is a determination to stick with Ardrossan with all the problems over the years. I also fear that things will not get any better when the Glen Sannox becomes operational.
I also remember on a number of occasions during stormy weather the ferry running between Brodick and Gourock. Perhaps this was in the days before Caledonian Isles, but I wonder what happened to this option?
In conclusion, I would like to make it clear that I am not critical in any way of CalMac and its staff who do a great job and generally are always cheery even under the worst conditions. We are told that with climate change we can expect more extreme weather and for Arran residents and visitors a reliable ferry service is essential. Of course there will always be exceptions when the service must be cancelled (and if you have any doubts read the story of the Princess Victoria lost in January 1953) but I wonder if Ardrossan is a common thread and if all the alternative options have been fully explored.
Yours,
Michael Smith, North Shields.