The Courier & Advertiser (Angus and Dundee)
Swinney speaks up for educational standards during heated debate
HOLYROOD: Deputy first minister defends Scottish Government while admitting average ‘not good enough’
Education Secretary John Swinney defended the Scottish Government’s efforts at improving education but admitted average “was not good enough” during questioning at Holyrood.
Mr Swinney was responding to questions in the chamber in the wake of the publication of the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) results which showed standards in science and maths had fallen.
He accused the Scottish Conservatives of “talking Scottish education down” after they pointed out results had fallen under the SNP.
Compared to the rest of the world, Scotland’s results in maths and science among 15 to 16-year-olds was “average” to the OECD, but in reality had slipped on comparable results in 2016.
The deputy first minister, parachuted into the Scottish Government’s education secretary role following years as economy secretary, pointed out the standards in reading had improved since 2016.
PISA results in maths have dropped every year since 2006 in Scotland and are now “significantly” behind England and Northern Ireland.
“It is an appalling indictment... and a shameful legacy to bequeath our children. SCOTTISH CONSERVATIVE DEPUTY LEADER LIAM KERR
Scottish Conservative deputy leader and North East MSP Liam Kerr said: “Our PISA results show Scotland at a record low.
“It is an appalling indictment of this government’s mismanagement and a shameful legacy to bequeath our children. Does the cabinet secretary have any idea how to arrest this slide?”
Mr Swinney responded: “Liam Kerr could have said Scotland’s reading score had improved significantly, but he indulges in the perpetual anti-education agenda of the Scottish Consevatives, which is all about talking down Scottish education.
“They took a hammering (in last week’s election) and were sent homeward to think again. Scottish education is improving, while the Scottish Conservatives are going downhill fast.”
Mr Swinney had earlier said: “Our progress in science and maths in 2018 is showing at the average. The results are stable but stable is not good enough.
“We have measures we have put in place to drive up standards across Scotland and in particular to reduce the poverty-related attainment gap.”
PISA 2018 figures show Scotland achieved a mean score of 504 for reading, up from 493 in 2015; 489 for maths, down from 491 in 2015; and 490 for science, down from 497 in 2015.
With the rise in performance for reading, Scotland returns to a similar level recorded in 2012, when it was 506.
In maths, performance dropped on the 491 figure in 2015 and is at its lowest level, having fallen in every PISA survey since a high of 524 in 2003.
In science, Scotland’s level of performance has also continued to fall over the last decade, with a score of 497 in 2015 and 515 in 2006.