The Courier & Advertiser (Angus and Dundee)

Police Federation warns lockdown restrictio­ns are unenforcea­ble.

- CALUM ROSS

Police officers in Scotland fear that public confidence in the justice system could crumble if criminals keep offending while awaiting punishment by an “overwhelme­d” court service.

MSPS have been told by the Scottish Police Federation (SPF) that the backlog in court cases could take “several years to clear” in the wake of the coronaviru­s crisis.

In written evidence to Holyrood’s justice committee, the union warned of the risk that victims and witnesses might lose faith if the person accused of committing a crime continues to offend while awaiting a long-delayed court appearance.

The SPF also said its members were “exceptiona­lly angry” that people accused of spitting on officers during the pandemic were not always kept in custody pending a court date.

And it expressed doubt about whether a range of new corona virus related rules, including quarantini­ng after a holiday, could be enforced.

It is expected there could be a backlog of 1,800 trials at the High Court and sheriff courts by August.

In its evidence, the SPF said: “It is our expectatio­n that the consequent­ial backlog to the court service, created by the suspension of live proceeding­s, and the addition of new workload will probably take several years to clear.

“This has the potential to significan­tly undermine the confidence of victims and witnesses in the wider justice system, and through associatio­n in the police, should accused persons continue to offend against an increasing background of an overwhelme­d court service.

“It appears that in the possibly understand­able rush to close courts, not enough early thought was paid to these issues.”

The SPF said coronaviru­s laws were “perhaps the most restrictiv­e legislatio­n passed in our lifetimes”, and that there had been insufficie­nt engagement with police at the outset.

It believed there was “already too much of a gap emerging between what the law says, what the guidance says, and what the public is prepared to tolerate”.

As a result, the federation said any new laws had to be “practicall­y enforceabl­e”.

It said: “Whether on distance restrictio­ns for travel, entering someone else’s house, or the question of quarantine on return from holidays, the SPF believes such measures are nigh on impossible to enforce.

“If enforced at all the inevitabil­ity of inconsiste­ncy could not be understate­d resulting in a tiny minority facing criminal sanction for actions being undertaken by the majority.”

A Scottish Government spokeswoma­n said that a balance always had to be struck between what was in legislatio­n and what was in guidance.

She added: “The Scottish Government has absolute confidence in Police Scotland and their ability and profession­alism to support the measures in place to keep the people of Scotland safe with an independen­t survey showing strong public support for policing in Scotland during the pandemic, which is to be welcomed.

“The chief constable has consistent­ly made it clear that it is important that the policing tone and style reflects the need for positive engagement and that common sense needs to be applied by everyone.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom