The Courier & Advertiser (Angus and Dundee)

‘Sleekit’ Markets Bill is a threat to Scotland

-

Sir, – This Brexit Project appears to be disintegra­ting before our very eyes.

The Internal Market Bill ignores our values and is underminin­g powers devolved to Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland, so has been described as a power grab.

The Bill is sleekit, it leaves devolved powers untouched but creates new reservatio­ns in our devolved areas.

There are two market access principles set out in the Bill.

Mutual recognitio­n where goods which can be lawfully sold in England can be sold anywhere whether or not they meet local standards.

So often quoted is chlorinate­d chicken bred in dank sheds in USA until they reach their weight.

If they are good enough for diners in Preston then they are good enough for a supermarke­t in Perth.

Holyrood opts to keep animal welfare and food standards high but under this Bill none of the Scottish regulation­s will matter.

So good to go in England means the same for Scotland.

I feel for the farmers here who raise chickens and other animals to a very high standard.

The second principle of non-discrimina­tion is more complex.

The goverment can restrict free movement of goods, set import quotas or tariffs.

In 2019, President

Trump imposed a 25% tariff on Scottish malt, cashmere and confection­ery whilst ignoring such products in Italy, Belgium etc.

One has to ask what Westminste­r has done to sort this problem?

Under this Bill if any measure from the devolved parliament­s make it difficult or unattracti­ve to sell or buy goods from another part of the UK this becomes discrimina­tory.

Minimum pricing of alcohol in Scotland is a case in point.

Created because of health issues here and after a long legal process the EU and courts agreed this was justified.

This Bill gives any UK Minister the power to knock this out with the stroke of a pen.

The Bill also gives the UK Government the power to dole out cash on pet projects across the UK by passing the devolved assemblies on economic, cultural, educationa­l issues etcetera.

The Welsh government have pointed out the UK is not like the EU.

The UK is imposing the mutual recognitio­n and non discrimina­tion on the three nations, whereas the EU single market member states voluntaril­y agree a set of rules.

This is Scotland’s future at stake here.

If you go to bed in a bee hive and waken up stung who is to blame?

Ian Wallace. Chapman Drive, Carnoustie.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom