The Courier & Advertiser (Fife Edition)

All the jealousy and heartache you’d expect

- with Paul Whitelaw

There is no such thing as good and evil, just endless gradients of misfortune. As one of the quietly dismayed detectives in American Justice sighed, “People make terrible mistakes.”

This new documentar­y series, sculpted in the shade of Netflix’s highly acclaimed Making a Murderer, sheds light on Florida’s notoriousl­y harsh justice system.

A Republican stronghold, Jacksonvil­le has the dubious honour of being known as the state’s murder capital. Controvers­ial state attorney Angela Corey practicall­y revels in her notorious record for sending so many convicts to death row.

Like a real-life version of The Wire, the cameras focused on various levels of the hierarchy, from Corey in her all-powerful

seat of government all the way down to the alleged criminals fighting for their lives.

The two crimes in question were a double-homicide involving a man and his niece, and the killing of a young black man, whose cousin, Trey Wright, had been accused of committing the murder.

A creeping sense of dread permeated proceeding­s, as we followed grieving loved ones, patient detectives, conflicted prosecutor­s and the petrified accused.

In the end, Trey was cleared of all charges. He didn’t murder anyone. A lucky escape.

The programme’s message was gravely apparent throughout: the death penalty is abhorrent.

An eye for an eye? Fine, why don’t you physically and literally pluck out that eye? Or just let prisoners rot in jail. Isn’t that punishment enough?

Here’s a thought, America. Your second amendment? Scrap it. It was written by people more than 200 years ago who lived in fear of being mauled by bears. That fear no longer exists.

There is no justificat­ion for keeping guns at home. If you ban guns, then gun crime will recede. It’s that simple.

Then again, this is the country that elected a brazenly stupid, petulant child-man as president so there’s probably no hope for it at all.

And if you think I’m using this TV column to express my own political views, then you’re right.

But that’s because television is a window into the soul of our sick, rotten society. It’s your own reflection, whether you like it or not. More jokes next week, folks! Meanwhile, if you needed further proof that human beings are ridiculous creatures, then your deepest fears would have been confirmed by the new documentar­y series Three Wives, One Husband.

In the programme the polygamous lives of a Utah desert Mormon sect are presented as a sad microcosm of our never-ending ability to delude ourselves for no logical reason whatsoever.

According to their fundamenta­list religious beliefs, this enclosed community regard men as earthly manifestat­ions of God Himself, here to sire as many children as possible.

This necessitat­es the taking of several wives, which naturally leads to all the jealousy, insecurity and heartache you’d expect.

Enoch, our protagonis­t, definitely has a type. His two wives and potential third look practicall­y identical.

The women spoke candidly about their fears while desperatel­y struggling to justify the pain they’ve pointlessl­y endured.

One of them argued that polygamy keeps their marriage fresh, as the periods her husband spends with his other families makes her lonely heart grow fonder. She was fooling no one. Despite the potentiall­y lurid subject matter, the programme doesn’t mock these essentiall­y nice, harmless people. It merely shakes its head in sympathy and despair.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom