The Courier & Advertiser (Fife Edition)

Corbyn must change his party’s culture

-

Sir, – Fife councillor Mary Lockhart has been suspended following a Facebook post criticisin­g the editorial stance of some Jewish newspapers (Courier, July 31).

The sooner Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn tries to resolve the larger issue by adoption of the Internatio­nal Holocaust Remembranc­e Alliance code on anti -Semitism the better it will be for his party’s unity and public image.

It won’t, however, solve a basic problem.

The code is simply a guide – it can be interprete­d in a number of different ways.

Since few people will have ever read it, it is worth quoting the text: “Anti-Semitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred towards Jews. Rhetorical and physical manifestat­ions of this are directed towards Jewish or non-Jewish individual­s and/or their property, towards Jewish institutio­ns and religious facilities”.

These words shouldn’t rule out civilised debate about the complex Israel-Palestine situation, or the role of the Israeli intelligen­ce service.

Israel is not the only country in the world that is involved in territoria­l disputes; Mossad is not the only intelligen­ce service in the world whose activities draw controvers­y.

People ought to be able to criticise without using offensive language that could be seen as anti-Jewish, anti-Islam, anti-Christian or anti-Buddhist.

There are always problems, though, in suggesting that any of these groups is involved in an internatio­nal conspiracy to subvert justice.

Therein lies the real challenge for Labour and Mr Corbyn.

It is as much a matter of culture and protocol as anything else.

Bob Taylor.

24 Shiel Court, Glenrothes.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom