The Courier & Advertiser (Fife Edition)
Road ban for driver who caused A9 smash that put soldier out of action
Adangerous driver has avoided a prison sentence after causing a horrific smash on the A9 which left a Scottish war hero out of action.
Regimental sergeant major Ian Carlisle was travelling through Highland Perthshire when a van driven by Marvin Aryeetey crossed into his path.
The Inverness soldier, who serves with the 7th Battalion The Royal Regiment of Scotland (7 Scots), tried to veer off the road but was unable to avoid a collision.
Both men were trapped inside their wrecked vehicles and had to be rescued by fire crews.
Mr Carlisle suffered multiple injuries and underwent four operations following the crash in October 2019.
On Wednesday, Aryeetey appeared at Perth Sheriff Court having previously admitted a charge of dangerous driving. He was banned from the road for two years.
The 47-year-old was also placed on a restriction of liberty curfew for six months, meaning he must stay at home between 7pm and 7am each day.
Solicitor Nigel Bruce said “This was a serious collision. Mr Aryeetey was in hospital for six weeks as result, while the driver of the other car is still suffering.”
He said: “My client shows complete remorse for his actions and he has shown great concern for Mr Carlisle.
“Mr Aryeetey suffers from poor health, not just as a result of this crash.”
The court heard Aryeetey, of Broomhouse Row, Edinburgh, damaged his pelvis and hip in the accident.
“But he is not looking for sympathy,” said Mr Bruce. “He is someone who could carry out unpaid work.
“There are clearly alternatives to a custodial sentence in this case.”
The court heard insurers had paid out to Mr Carlisle.
Sheriff Linda Smith told Aryeetey: “This is clearly a very serious accident which you have accepted liability for.”
The smash happened on a single carriageway section of the A9, about 500 metres north of the Dunkeld junction.
Fiscal depute Michael Sweeney said 47-year-old Aryeetey, who has an unblemished licence and no previous criminal convictions, was driving south at the time of the smash.
“It was dark that evening, the weather was damp and traffic flow was light,” he said. “At about 9pm, Mr Carlisle was travelling north in his works’ car, a black Ford Ranger, with the intention of heading into Inverness.”
Mr Sweeney said: “Mr Carlisle observed three vehicles travelling south. Suddenly, he saw the accused’s van move fully into his lane, as if he was trying to overtake.
“The van was only about 20 metres from his vehicle. There was not enough time or distance for accused to overtake.”
Mr Sweeney told the court: “Mr Carlisle immediately took evasive action and steered into the nearside verge in an attempt to avoid a collision. “However, both vehicles collided within the northbound lane, driver’s side to driver’s side.
“Another motorist had to take evasive action to avoid and collided with the accused’s van which had travelled backwards along the northbound lane.
“Witnesses immediately attended at both vehicles and saw that both accuser and complainer were trapped inside.
“Emergency services were called and both men were cut free from their vehicles by firefighters, and passed to the care of ambulance staff.”
Mr Sweeney said: “Mr Carlisle was admitted to Ninewells Hospital where he was diagnosed with a dislocated wrist and a fracture on his radius bone which required a metal plate and wires being fitted.
“He also suffered a dislocated right elbow. The elbow was reset and another metal plate was fitted.”
“Mr Carlisle was expected to get back to full health in about three to six months, depending on how well the physiotherapy went.
“He has had four operations and has been signed off from work.”