The Courier & Advertiser (Fife Edition)
Open mind is key to society in harmony
Sir, – Regarding Paul Read (Letters, May 16), evolution is a rationally verifiable scientific theory. It is called a theory because it can never be proven, but the odds of it being unfounded are miniscule especially as we can see evolution happen.
The odds against creationism get increasingly small with our ever-developing scientific knowledge and understanding.
Science does not disprove creationism per se, which is why many eminent scientists didn’t or don’t exclude the possibility.
What creationists cannot answer is where the creator came from, or what it actually is, and “always been there” is not a rational answer other than to mollify the naïve.
The creationists however use as absolute proof a collection of extrapolated myths not based on any actual evidence written with hindsight and wordof-mouth repetition several hundred years later. This does not mean that some event or other didn’t happen but they have been retrospectively interpreted to suit the level of knowledge at the time of writing. Such writings cannot be considered as proof, but also do not mean that people cannot gain comfort from them while using them as a base for their own moral stance and lifestyle.
However, when I mentioned imposition by force I was referring to the various pogroms, crusades, inquisitions and indeed more recent inter-creed disputes invariably spilling over into intense violence.
Invariably on the basis that “my God is better than your God”, which is also irrational if there is only one “God”, scientists are open to proof and are prepared to change their views.
Creationists are absolutely certain they are right despite the lack of actual evidence in their favour.
Sadly those who support rigid views and absolutism are unwilling to analyse their own thinking.
People are entitled to believe what they wish, but in the absence of rational evidence they cannot and should not be absolutely certain they are right and everybody else is wrong.
Having an open mind is key to a harmonious society.
Nick Cole.
Balmacron Farmhouse,
Meigle.