In defence of Jenny Hjul

Sir, – I feel compelled to counter the criticism of your columnist, Ms Hjul, by Colin Mayall. (Courier Letters, November 23).

Why is it, when anyone dares to criticise the SNP or any of its ministers, there is an automatic response of “hatred” of nationalism levied against the critic?

If Mr Mayall cares to look at the record of the SNP in power at Holyrood, he would perhaps notice the track-record of fiscal incompetence, and the habit of blaming Westminster for the ills that have befallen Scotland under the SNP’s watch.

The most glaring defects of the first minister include her habit of talking over anyone who disagrees with her during televised interviews, her failure to differentiate between aspiration and policy, and her unfailing habit to meddle in affairs that go beyond the brief and mandate of the devolved government at Holyrood.

So more power to Ms Hjul’s elbow in showing up such deficiencies.

Perhaps, as a result, she will cause the first minister and her acolytes to reconsider the Holyrood role and responsibilities in Scotland, and the best way of achieving desired outcomes.

They may also realise these are not helped by the theatricals of Ian Blackford or the football antics of Hannah Bardell. Derek Farmer. Knightsward Farm, Anstruther.