The Courier & Advertiser (Perth and Perthshire Edition)
Law killer release scandal
Dundee grandmother left for dead by convicted murderer welcomes damning report into his release from prison
● Police and prison bosses slammed in damning report into Law killer’s early release.
● Experts warned Robbie McIntosh was a ‘high risk’ of reoffending.
● Justice Secretary Humza Yousaf apologises to attack victim Linda McDonald.
The Dundee grandmother left for dead by Law killer Robbie McIntosh has said she hopes a damning report into his release from prison will protect the public from violent criminals in the future.
Linda McDonald, 54, was walking her dog Betsy in Templeton Woods when McIntosh attacked her with a dumb-bell.
Murderer McIntosh had been convicted of killing civil servant Anne Nicoll on Dundee Law in 2001 when he was just 15.
He was on home leave from prison 16 years later when he tried to kill Mrs McDonald in the woods near her home.
McIntosh fled the scene after being interrupted by two dog walkers and ran to his mother’s house in nearby Bridgefoot, on the outskirts of Dundee.
Police arrested him minutes after the attack and he was jailed for an “indeterminate” length of time after admitting attempted murder.
Mrs McDonald criticised the decision to let McIntosh out from prison for periods of his sentence and has campaigned for an end to unsupervised home leave for convicted killers.
She said yesterday’s publication of the Significant Case Review into the decisions that led to McIntosh’s release vindicated her claims and lifted “an unbearable weight” from her shoulders.
Ms McDonald said: “It’s a long time
I’ve been waiting for this report. It has taken a long time.
“While you can appreciate it was a complex issue, when you are in my shoes the weight is unbearable.”
Mrs McDonald said there had been serious failings in how McIntosh’s case had been managed.
The Significant Case Review found a 2012 psychological assessment showed McIntosh indicated a high risk of reoffending.
It said the recommendation to grant McIntosh temporary release from prison had not been balanced and the risk management strategy appeared to “have concentrated on his journey towards community access” rather than managing identified risks.
It also identified a number of failings, such as local police in Angus not being informed McIntosh had been released on home leave in August 2017.
McIntosh had also been experimenting with so-called legal highs and it was known drug use may have been a factor in his offending.
While on home leave, he was often left “to his own devices” and had no structure or supervision.
Mrs McDonald said: “The big weight off my shoulders is that all of the questions I asked, all of my beliefs that there were mistakes and failings have been proved right.”
She added: “The reason I put myself through this Significant Case Review is so they don’t let this happen to anybody else.
“You can’t change the past but you try to do everything you can to ask what went wrong and be transparent, and make sure the failings in your ‘robust system’ never happen again.”
Police were called to Templeton Woods in August 2017 after two dog walkers interrupted McIntosh’s attack.
Mrs McDonald was left with a series of life-altering injuries. She required 35 stitches and staples in five head wounds.
Her thumb had to be reattached after it was damaged as she tried to ward off blows from McIntosh.
She was in hospital for three days after the attack before defying doctors’ advice to return home, where she spent several weeks in bed recovering.
You can’t change the past but you try to do everything you can to ask what went wrong. LINDA MCDONALD
The unprovoked attack on Linda McDonald last year shook the public’s faith in the prison service to its very core. Convicted murdered Robbie McIntosh was on home leave when he tired to kill the Dundee grandmother in a shocking explosion of violence.
The impact of his sickening crime on Linda is unimaginable. She sustained life-changing injuries and is unlikely to ever make a full recovery.
The authorities have gone to great lengths to stress McIntosh’s murderous impulses were unpredictable and only he bears blame for the attack on Linda.
This is undoubtedly true.
But it is also obvious that McIntosh should never have been allowed out to commit this foul crime.
The questions the Significant Case Review, published yesterday, sought to answer were why this had been allowed to happen and why monitoring of a dangerous offender was so lax.
Former detective Mark Cooper uncovered a series of systematic and unforgiveable failures on the part of the police, social workers and senior prison staff.
It also revealed too much time was spent planning ways to “mitigate” the impact of media interest in McIntosh’s release.
Many will conclude the authorities’ priorities are too slanted towards rehabilitation rather than public safety.