Call for vigilance on carbon credits

Scottish farmers have been reminded of the growing risks of losing control of carbon credits on land that will be needed to offset the industry’s own greenhouse gas emissions.

The complexity of the auditing, calculation and trading of carbon was laid bare at an NFU Scotland (NFUS) webinar, where farmers were asked to consider three key points ahead of the union’s response to the UK Emissions Trading Scheme consultation.

Many of the 100 or more producers who watched the webinar responded positively to questions which asked if a standardised carbon calculator was required, if carbon trading should be available to provide an income for farmers and crofters, and if the carbon trading market should be regulated.

The demand by the major polluters – manufacturing, aviation and heavy industry

– for ways of offsetting their emissions has already led to heightened values for Scottish land, particularly if it is suitable for planting trees.

However, the union’s climate policy manager, Kate Hopper, emphasised the importance of Scottish farming putting its own house in order by balancing its emissions before looking at whether there are

opportunities elsewhere. She said: “We have a responsibility in legislation to get ourselves as close to net zero as possible, but carbon trading is already happening, there’s already a market for it and that’s not going to go away.

“We need to decide where we draw the line, and what we do before we allow ourselves to carbon

trade – like all other industries are doing already.”

The union’s policy director, Jonnie Hall, also insisted the industry should be wary of selling its green credentials as future farm support is likely to be weighted towards farmers who not only take action to reduce their emissions but also to sequester carbon.

Ms Hopper highlighted the fact that carbon credits can be used only once and she said there is still ambiguity of the ownership of credits on tenanted land. She said that training and new “green” skills would be needed to help farmers understand the new market.

As a first steep, NFUS president Martin Kennedy advised farmers to take advantage of the opportunity to complete carbon audits as part of the Scottish Government’s £51 million National Test Programme to get accurate measurements.

DIG IN: Carbon credits can be used only once and there is still ambiguity over their ownership on tenanted land.

Kate Hopper emphasises the need for more training.