The Daily Telegraph

The sonnets addressed to men rather than women

-

Scholars who believe Shakespear­e was gay or bisexual base much of their argument on his sonnets. Most of the sonnets, particular­ly some considered to be the most idealised, are addressed to men rather than to women.

Sonnet 20 is often at the centre of debate. It begins: “A woman’s face with nature’s own hand painted / Hast thou, the master mistress of my passion.”

And the end couplet is: “But since she [Nature] prick’d thee out for women’s pleasure, / Mine be thy love and thy love’s use their treasure.”

Sir Stanley Wells said Sonnet 133 “implies that he is involved in a triangular affair with a man and a woman; he writes of it with anguish and implies that both his male and his female lover have abandoned him in a manner that deprives him of his sense of identity: ‘Of him, myself, and thee I am forsaken.’ So it seems pretty clear that he had at least one actively gay relationsh­ip.”

Sir Stanley went on: “In his plays, the most clearly gay couple are Patroclus and Achilles in the partly historical Troilus and

Cressida. You can’t avoid playing them as gay. In

Twelfth Night, the sea-captain Antonio speaks of his desire ‘sharp

as fil’d steel’ for the young Viola’s twin brother, Sebastian, which is pretty unambiguou­s, and in The Merchant of Venice

another Antonio offers his life for the man he loves, Bassanio, who however is in love with, and marries, a woman, Portia. ‘Love’ doesn’t necessaril­y imply a sexual relationsh­ip, but it’s hard to avoid, and most production­s over the past half century have played Antonio as gay.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom