The Daily Telegraph

Abortion law on line in row over top US judge

Donald Trump’s nominee for Supreme Court post splits opinion amid fears he could overturn test case

- By Nick Allen in Washington

THE future of America’s abortion law is on the line as a ferocious battle looms over Donald Trump’s latest nominee to sit on the US Supreme Court. Democrats vowed to do everything in their power over the next few months to block the appointmen­t of Brett Kavanaugh, a conservati­ve judge, to the country’s highest judicial body, while Republican­s said they would “lift heaven and Earth” to have him confirmed.

Politician­s on both sides began rallying supporters, and millions of dollars are set to be spent on advertisem­ents, as Judge Kavanaugh becomes a focal point for the midterm congressio­nal elections in November.

The judge has to be confirmed in the US Senate where Republican­s currently have a razor-thin 51-49 majority. He would replace Justice Anthony Kennedy who acted as a swing vote between the four conservati­ves and four liberals on the court, siding with liberals on a number of social issues including abortion.

Judge Kavanaugh’s confirmati­on could lead in the next few years to an overturnin­g of Roe v Wade, the landmark Supreme Court ruling of 1973 that establishe­d a constituti­onal right to abortion across the US. If overturned that would allow individual states to impose tight restrictio­ns on abortion. Activists on both sides of the debate said the future of abortion in America was in the balance.

Marjorie Dannenfels­er, president of Susan B. Anthony List, the anti-abortion group, said: “I have great hope that now there may be five judges to allow states to enact their own policies into law on the abortion issue.”

Dana Singiser, spokesman for the pro-choice Planned Parenthood Federation of America, said: “There’s no way to sugarcoat it, with this nomination, the constituti­onal right to access safe, legal abortion in this country is on the line.”

At 53, Judge Kavanaugh could sit on the court for decades, shifting it to the right on other issues too, including gun rights, campaign financing, deregulati­on and the rolling back of Obamacare.

He has not publicly stated that he would vote to overturn Roe v. Wade. However, last October, while sitting on the Appeals Court in Washington, he voted against other judges who permitted a teenage illegal immigrant in US custody to have an abortion. Judge Kavanaugh, who is Catholic, was unveiled as the nominee live on television by Mr Trump following an Apprentice-style selection procedure.

Speaking in the East Room of the White House, the judge said: “I will keep an open mind in every case. I will tell each senator that I revere the Constituti­on.”

Mr Trump praised him as a “judge’s judge” and “a brilliant jurist”. The president said he had not discussed Roe v Wade with his choice.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom