The Daily Telegraph

Saving the planet is great therapy for Greta Thunberg

- Melanie Mcdonagh

You’d have to have an even harder heart than mine not to feel for Greta Thunberg’s parents, opera singer Malena Ernman and her Abba-look dad, Svante Thunberg. In their book, Our House Is On Fire, they talk about the difficulti­es of raising Greta. She was diagnosed with highfuncti­oning Asperger’s

– a kind of autism. What’s more, she stopped eating. It must be hell to watch your child take two hours and 10 minutes to eat five gnocchi, not enough to sustain life.

Greta was different and she was bullied. At school she hid in the lavatories to get away from the children being horrible to her.

But Greta worked out her own salvation. She watched a programme in school about plastic polluting the Pacific and it changed her. At breakfast, she declared to her mother, who had to fly to work in different countries: “You celebritie­s are basically to the environmen­t what anti-immigrant politician­s are to multicultu­ral society.” Her point was: “Nothing conveys success and prosperity better than luxury, abundance and travel.”

So she started her school strike for the climate outside the Swedish PM’S office and, through social media, it took off. Her mother writes: “Although more than anything we want her to drop the whole idea of going on strike from school – we support her. Because we see that she feels good as she draws up her plans. Better than ever before.”

Then Ivan from Greenpeace offered Greta vegan noodles as she camped on the street. She took it. She was saved from self-starvation. And with countless teenagers around the world following her lead, her Asperger’s wasn’t just cured; it was validated.

A happy outcome, then, for her family. Her campaign for environmen­tal austerity, which has taken her from the UN to Davos, trailing celebs in her wake, shows that the personal really is political. Greta’s teenage world view doesn’t have room for complexity and that’s not her fault. But grown-ups must. Dairy farmers would go out of business if we all become vegan. Blanket tree-planting would damage eco-diversity.

What the book makes you wonder is this: is the disruption caused by Greta’s single-minded crusade to save the planet really a giant exercise in family therapy?

Zara Steiner, who was my director of studies at Cambridge, is buried today. She was a fine historian – her best-known book is The Lights That Failed about the interwar years – but many people knew her as the wife of George Steiner, that rare bird, a bona fide intellectu­al.

She was a wonderful tutor, and kind and maternal with it. She was never strident. Years ago, she told me about her meeting with Doris Lessing, the South African novelist. Lessing asked her abruptly after they met: “Are you a feminist?” “No,” said Dr Steiner. “Neither am I,” said Doris Lessing. Makes you think, doesn’t it?

Boris Johnson has cheered up those simple souls who like puns by calling for shorter briefs. He wants his civil servants to confine their briefing notes to two sheets of A4 paper. For his detractors, it’s more proof that he’s a slacker. Actually, it shows he’s still a journalist. Any fool can write enormous screeds about a complex subject; it takes an intelligen­t person’s effort to make it simple and short. As a clever man once observed: “I am sorry to have written such a long letter; I did not have the time to make it short.”

 ??  ??
 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom