The Daily Telegraph

Antidotes to our age of instant gratificat­ion are all around us

- JANE SHILLING

Six months after the illegal felling of the Sycamore Gap tree, discussion continues about how to restore the site. The destructio­n of the iconic tree, planted by the 19thcentur­y lawyer and antiquaria­n John Clayton, was felt as a bereavemen­t across the world, and devastated a natural and human ecosystem. The habitat of birds and insects; Clayton’s legacy; the memories of generation­s of local people and, more recently, of tourists who snapped selfies in front of its gracious and enduring backdrop – were all lost.

A conversati­on immediatel­y began about how to repair the damage. But the days when amateur archaeolog­ists could plant a tree where they chose are long gone. For the various responsibl­e parties, including the National Trust, Northumber­land National Parks Authority and Historic England, navigating the necessary blend of consolatio­n, ecology and archaeolog­y to fulfil the need for a “legacy” has been a delicate matter.

Suggestion­s have included a stone circle, a metal replica tree, art installati­ons made from its trunk and a “place for reflection” (as though all natural landscapes – and many human-made ones – didn’t already provide that).

Yet the legacy could be simpler than any of these rather fanciful ideas. Salvaged twigs and seeds have been cultivated at a secret conservati­on centre. Some 45 seedlings and five grafted trees have flourished, and if the stump doesn’t re-sprout, a seedling could take its place.

The temptation to make a more emphatic statement, in order to replicate the impact of the lost tree, must be strong. By contrast, the quiet message of a seedling is: “Wait for a century or so, and see.” Yet this is the fundamenta­l story of all tree planting. Around the time that Hadrian’s wall was built, the Romans brought to Britain a tradition of planting for future generation­s. Our own century’s taste for instant gratificat­ion was foreshadow­ed by the great landscape gardeners of the 18th century, who didn’t scruple to re-site full-grown trees – though a contempora­ry writer noted that such trees “grow so slowly as to remind one of stricken deer”.

Embedded in the discussion about the future of the Sycamore Gap site is a deeper question about our ideas of landscape. The vandalised tree was mourned as though it were a human acquaintan­ce for whom death was obliterati­on. Yet trees are that fashionabl­e thing: a renewable resource (albeit with an unfashiona­bly long time-lag).

A seedling planted in the gap would mature to delight our great-grandchild­ren a century hence. Our ancestors embraced the long view, and so should we. Instead of the factitious consolatio­ns of a stone circle, an art installati­on or replica tree: a slender seedling could represent a sturdy statement of continuity with the past, and faith in the future.

The culinary tastes of Hollywood celebritie­s are notoriousl­y unrobust – running to little more than egg-white omelette and arugula salad.

But last night at the Oscars, the Cornish-born chef Elliott Grover offered a menu of sturdy British classics, including miniature servings of fish and chips, and beef with Yorkshire pudding.

Grover’s British cuisine was a triumph last year, as celebritie­s encountere­d the novel concept of food that actually tasted of something.

So whither, gastronomi­cally speaking, for next year’s Academy Awards? Tiny mouthfuls of black pudding, and doll-sized portions of pie and mash, perhaps?

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom