Hoka One One

£180

754g (size 4)

lightweight

shape, midsole, sole unit, lacing, tongue padding

Uppers: nubuck leather, Gore-Tex Mid/outsole: dual density EVA, rubberised foam/ Vibram Megagrip, 5mm lugs

Sizes: 3.5-9.5 (men 7-13.5) hokaoneone.eu

This is the first time I’ve tested Hoka

One One. Despite being the lightest by more than 200g/pair, they felt sort of flappy, like walking in small snowshoes. Perhaps it was the foam in the midsole; but even with my orthotics I could feel no support, as though my feet were sinking. After two hours’ walking my feet felt strained so I had my gait videoed, and it seems to relate to heel strike. The splayed heel is 9.5cm at its widest point, fully 2cm wider than the next widest boots (Hanwag, Meindl) and more than 50% wider than Scarpa at 6.2cm. It also protrudes 2cm behind my heel, and with the footbed is minimum 1cm higher above the ground than the others. Result: my heel/feet were hitting the ground in a very different place – height and angle – to normal (and not in a good way). I asked the brand for the reason behind this construction. Response: “The Hoka difference is delivered in part by this geometry, the bucket seat, and the meta-rocker, [which] when combined provide a uniquely smooth and supportive cushioning system.” Uppers are flexible leather and synthetic, with a soft synthetic cuff, high enough for two hooks. Lacing is split into four sectors, each adjusted independently. The highest hook is near the cuff top yet the tongue is minimally padded, so care is needed to avoid pressure across the foot and when tying off laces. Vibram sole has 5mm lugs for grip with no heel ledge: it is centrally flat, with heel and toe rockers. Sidewall support was minimal; I would not use these on steep or technical terrain. If you are accustomed to walking in sandals, trainers or very soft boots, they could work for you. They don’t work for me.