The Independent

Our school system is broken and I blame the Tories

-

Goodbye to education. I have been a teacher for five years, in that time I have worked at three schools, I have worked for nine headteache­rs, seen the arts get sidelined and squeezed, and unimaginab­le cuts. The education system is broken.

Of the nine headteache­rs I have worked for, some were more suited to the role than others, but all of them were passionate about education. However, there is an instant result culture, driven by data in education. This is similar to football managers, with headteache­rs being forced out and not given time to succeed.

I feel very scared for the arts; they have been continuall­y sidelined and under supported. School Leadership Team members push students into humanities and languages, rather than allowing them to follow their passion in the arts. Again, this is because of data and league tables. There is no considerat­ion for what the student wants/needs. Education is about offering a wide range of subjects. This will not happen with schools cutting the arts. If they want the good PR of a Christmas concert or a musical, they need to support to arts to make it happen.

The academy system does not work, it allows for people in governance to misuse public funds, provide poor governance and be corrupt (all things I have experience­d). This is because there is not enough accountabi­lity for academies. Schools need to be brought back under local authority. Schools should not be run as a business with students being called “stakeholde­rs”. Not all schools have had the poor financial management of my school. But all schools are being forced into debt by the systematic underfundi­ng of the education system by the Tory government. Schools are not replacing leaving staff and making redundanci­es, which has resulted in bigger class sizes and a poorer education experience for the students.

I am leaving for my own personal reasons, but I am leaving an education system I feel so passionate­ly about. There must be a huge overhaul of the education system. We need to turn our back on the data system as personal developmen­t cannot be measured in numbers. We ultimately need to “get the Tories out” to help save our schools.

I wish everyone who is in education good luck, I think you’re going to need it. Francis Short Address supplied

BBC men should take a pay cut

It would be good to see male employees at the BBC accept the same pay as women, rather than have licence-payers shell out loads of money to raise the salaries of women to equal that of men. They all earn way above the average pay of workers and none of them would suffer hardship by equalising pay in this way.

Betty Harris London N1

Why don’t the men take a cut in salary which gives them the same as women? The difference could then be put towards some decent programmes. Forget the “presenters,” let’s go back to commentato­rs who are voices and not screen hugging “stars”, and cut the constant background music – more savings. There you are – easy peasy – sorted!

Maggie Barker South of England

Food bank inequality

Safeeyah Kazi asks how Theresa May can claim that “inequality is down” (I visited a food bank this week to see how true Theresa May's slogans about inequality really are, Monday) when more people than ever are having to depend on food banks. Alas, I suspect that in Theresa May’s eyes, more people having to use food banks may be a sign of reduced inequality – after all, it does suggest a certain levelling of the playing field.

Julian Self Milton Keynes

We must all oppose the arms trade fair

Mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, wants to ban the Defence and Security Equipment Internatio­nal (DSEI) arms fair – the biggest in the world – from taking place in London in September, but he doesn’t have the power to stop it. As extraordin­ary-ordinary citizens of the UK, none of us has the power to stop the DSEI fair taking place, but we do have the right to protest about it. As an older woman who took direct action for women’s rights and environmen­tal rights in the 70s, that’s exactly what I plan to do, and I’m not alone.

Mr Khan, you may not have the power to ban the DSEI arms fair, but like the rest of us, you do have the right to protest about it if you choose to do so, and to bring it under public scrutiny in the process.

Rina Vergano Bristol

We need Tories in our progressiv­e Brexit alliance too

Some of yesterday’s letters passionate­ly underscore­d the despair that many of us feel over Brexit. But we need to recognise that Jeremy Corbyn is potentiall­y unreliable on this issue, as on many others. It appears that he didn’t make a commitment to write off student debt. It’s also becoming clearer that he didn’t really make a commitment to fight hard Brexit. With smoke and mirrors he seems to have generated his very own Nick Clegg moments. He will never be forgiven if he allows his natural, life-long antipathy to the EU to colour his judgement in the months ahead.

If we are to achieve a fairer society, and a sane and soft Brexit, the battlegrou­nd lies within the divided Conservati­ve party. The grown-ups, Hammond, Rudd, Ruth Davidson in Scotland, and the many moderate backbench MPs, need to rise up now and take on the appalling trio of Johnson, Davis and Fox, and, indeed, our vision-deprived Prime Minister.

Talk of a transition period offers a ray of light, and a way to diffuse the ticking time-bomb of Article 50. This could be the route to common sense, eventually a Norwegian-type solution, or, at the very least, continued membership of the Customs Union. But, it’s within the Conservati­ve Party that these issues will be decided. Moderate Conservati­ves must work with Liberal Democrats and mainstream Labour MPs on this and many other issues. If we cannot persuade moderate pro-European Tories to come out fighting, the

whole battle may be lost. John Gemmell Birmingham

Corbyn is letting us down

Jeremy Corbyn has confirmed that a Labour government would take the UK out of the single market, in effect dashing the hopes of those, especially young people, who turned to Labour in the recent election in the hope that it might choose to reverse Brexit. But that may not be the end of the story. Reversing austerity and many other Conservati­ve policies is more important to Labour than Brexit. Given that a future Labour government would be dependent on support from the Lib Dems and the SNP, it would not be to deny the “voice of the people” to campaign on the basis of leaving the single market, but to be forced to accept the impossibil­ity of enforcing it once in power.

Patrick Cosgrove Shropshire

Cancer can be a ‘battle’

I’m a cancer survivor (still on chemo), and Anthony Wilson’s most sincere and thoughtful sentiments (Obama's tweet to John McCain about his diagnosis was the last thing cancer survivors wanted to see, Monday) differ from mine significan­tly. I generally avoid “war words,” so I never considered that “battle” “hands responsibi­lity for recovery to the patient.” Some medical studies show that the patient’s frame-ofmind contribute­s to treatment success, so the patient is “involved” with a team of medical profession­als, adjunct care providers, and mental, emotional, social and spiritual supporters. So yes – I had a role in my survival; no – I wasn’t solely responsibl­e.

Through the surgeries, hospital stays, chemothera­py, radiation and chemo pills, it felt like a battle throughout my body! I inhaled the cliche that “I have cancer; cancer doesn’t have me!” It wasn’t about “only ‘strong’ or ‘deserving’ patients survive” ... in fact, Wilson’s correlatio­n of “battle” with “strong [and] deserving” puzzles me. I agree that “there is absolutely nothing romantic” about cancer; there is no inherent correlatio­n between ”battle“and ”romance.“

As for “Obama’s tweet,” a former President (Obama) sent a message to a former soldier, ex-prisoner-ofwar, and hero (Senator McCain). The sender used a frame-of-reference natural to the receiver. In recognisin­g this, not only was Obama’s message supportive, it honoured and respected McCain’s many accomplish­ments in terms McCain understand­s.

Travelling the cancer journey myself, knowing Obama’s and McCain’s background­s, Obama’s message brought tears as I read those encouragin­g, honourable, and respectful words: “John McCain is an American hero & one of the bravest fighters I’ve ever known. Cancer doesn‘t know what it’s up against. Give it hell, John.” I believe Obama’s tweet was spot on; the honour, respect, and collateral support and encouragem­ent is precisely what I – a cancer survivor – want to see!

Judy Bamberger O’Connor, Australia

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom