The Jewish Chronicle

‘Every clap tears at you inside. It is sickening’

- FIRST PERSON BY DAVID COLLIER David Collier is a pro-Israel activist and blogger

I WAS at the House of Lords for the launch of the “Balfour apology” campaign — a project that seeks to pressure the British government to apologise for the Balfour Declaratio­n as it approaches its 100th anniversar­y next year.

What occurred at the event led to the suspension and resignatio­n of Jenny Tonge from the Liberal Democrats.

The organisers, the Palestine Return Centre (PRC) later released a statement that attempted to smokescree­n the vile antisemiti­c atmosphere that was present.

The question of who is responsibl­e for the antisemiti­sm, speaker or guest, is a sideshow, designed to have us all engage in pointless discussion­s.

I heard Jews blamed for the Holocaust, I heard that Israelis are the real antisemite­s and that good Jews are only those that denounce Israel.

I heard talk of Jewish power. Classic antisemiti­c tropes where someone with little imaginatio­n simply replaces the word “Jew” with “Zionist” as he speaks.

All these comments received loud applause. There was even reference TheLordsme­etingmarke­dthelaunch­ofthePRC’s“Balfourapo­logy”campaign to quotes used in Holocaust conspiraci­es.

Let us not forget that last year Sir Gerald Kaufman launched an attack on Israel that included the phrase “Jewish money”, and spoke of Jews influencin­g the Conservati­ve Party. He went on to accuse Israel of fabricatin­g terror attacks. That too was inside Westminste­r at a PRC event. There was nothing new here.

And doesn’t that highlight the problem? It is over a decade since Jenny Tonge began with her virulent criticism of Israel. Since then, there has been a long list of statements ranging from accusation­s of Zionist financial and political control to those related to harvesting organs. Why did it take so long for the Lib Dems to act?

Why so many years to have Sir Gerald receive a rebuke from his party leader? Or Ken Livingston­e? How about Jackie Walker? If someone in power began persistent­ly targeting a minority, making outrageous accusation­s, distorting the truth and employing racists slurs, there is no way it would take a decade for serious action to be taken. Unless that minority is the Jews.

Just two days after this event I was at the UCL campus, surrounded by police and angry protesters during an intimidati­ng attempt to no platform an Israeli speaker at a student event. Jewish people seem to be the only minority that is expected to accept such a situation. As if we are meant to accommodat­e the “minority” that hates us.

Describing events, quoting comments and speaking of what occurred is a relatively straightfo­rward exercise.

What is difficult to describe is the sickening feeling of personally witnessing such an event. The emotional impact of being among people who carry an irrational hatred of the essence of what you are. Every clap tears at you inside.

You sense the level of antisemiti­sm rise as the evening progresses. Feeding off every display of Jew-hatred, witness the warm reception that it receives. And it is personal, the target of that hatred is me. They are talking about my family, my friends, my children, my nation.

It is an ingatherin­g of the similarlym­inded. Each finding an element of belonging, of personal vindicatio­n in being among those that simply view Jews the same way. The sort of meeting you would expect to happen in the dark, in secret, far, far away.

And then you look around and realise you are not inside some dark hut, hidden away to ensure such vile antisemiti­sm remains unnoticed. It is 2016 and you are sitting inside the halls of Westminste­r, at the heart of the British democratic estate.

Just how long will it take before someone finally says “enough”?

The target of that hatred is me, my family’

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United Kingdom