Rabbinate under fire over diaspora ‘blacklist’
THE ISRAELI Chief Rabbinate is under fire for keeping a list — called a “blacklist” by some media outlets — of diaspora rabbis whose authority to rule on somebody’s Jewishness it has rejected.
The rabbis in question have vouched that individuals from their communities are Jewish so that they can marry through the Israeli rabbinate. But according to the list, their testimonials were rejected in at least 160 cases in 2016.
There are five UK rabbis on the list — a document which, according to the Orthodox rabbi who publicised it, will drive a wedge between Israel and diaspora Jewry.
“It’s ridiculous,” said Seth Farber, head of Itim, a campaign group that obtained the list as part of its longrunning legal challenge to force the rabbinate to become more transparent about whose proof of Jewishness it accepts.
Rabbi Farber said of rabbinate officials: “They are disparaging diaspora rabbis. Israel-diaspora relations are fragile and important, to delegitimise rabbis and communities is to delegitimise the historic role of Israel.”
The revelation of the list caused embarrassment within Israel’s rabbinate. Israel’s Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi David Lau said he had been unaware of its existence, and apologised to the cofounder of Nefesh b’Nefesh, Rabbi Yehoshua Fass, whose name was included on the document.
However, rabbinate spokesman Koby Alter argued that the document did not constitute a “blacklist” — a description used by Rabbi Farber and widely repeated.
Mr Alter said that the list — which includes Orthodox, Conservative and Reform rabbis — was simply a record of which rabbis had had letters of testimony rejected. Rejection may be unrelated to the standing of the rabbi, he said, suggesting that it is sometimes because of a technicality with the submission or because it appeared faked. “There were applications from a rabbi signed in 2016 who died in 2012,” he said.
Mr Alter insisted: “There could
Embarrassed: Rabbi Lau have been lots of reasons that permission was not given, and there could be different cases for the same rabbi that were approved.”
The UK names include Rabbi Blue, presumably Rabbi Lionel Blue, the former convener of the Reform Beth Din, who died last year; Rabbi Rodney Mariner, another former convener of the Reform Beth Din; and Rabbi Mark Winer, a former senior rabbi of the West London Synagogue.
A fourth is Rabbi Daniel Glass, the name of an Orthodox rabbi who has lectured at the Jewish Learning Exchange and was rabbi of the Shomrei Hadath (Federation) Synagogue London — although it is not clear if this is the person intended.
The fifth spells out in Hebrew Rabbi Jeremy Goltick, a name which so far no one has been able to link to an individual, although there has been speculation it could be a misspelling of Rabbi Jeremy Collick, the former rabbi of Edgware Masorti Synagogue. They are diasparaging diaspora rabbis’